Hsu Chia-Ching, Tsai Shih-Hung, Tsai Pei-Jan, Chang Yin-Chi, Tsai Yi-Da, Chen Yin-Chung, Lai Kuan-Cheng, Wang Jen-Chun, Yang Tse-Chun, Liao Wen-I, Chen Sy-Jou
Tri-Service General Hospital Department of Emergency Medicine Taipei Taiwan.
National Defense Medical Center School of Medicine Taipei Taiwan.
J Acute Med. 2022 Dec 1;12(4):145-157. doi: 10.6705/j.jacme.202212_12(4).0003.
The coronavirus disease 2019 (COVID-19) pandemic has resulted in substantial impacts on all aspects of medical education. Modern health systems must prepare for a wide variety of catastrophic scenarios, including emerging infectious disease outbreaks and human and natural disasters. During the COVID-19 pandemic, while the use of traditional teaching methods has decreased, the use of online-based teaching methods has increased. COVID-19 itself and the accompanying infection control measures have restricted full-scale practice. Therefore, we developed an adapted hybrid model that retained adequate hands-on practice and educational equality, and we applied it with a group of undergraduate medical students participating in a mandatory disaster education course in a military medical school.
The course covered the acquisition of skills used in emergency and trauma scenarios through designated interdisciplinary modules on disaster responses. Several asynchronous and synchronous online webinars were used in this one-credit mandatory disaster and military medicine education course. To allow opportunities for hands-on practice and ensure education equality, the students were divided into 15 groups, with 12 students in each group. The hands-on practice exercises were also recorded and disseminated to the students in the designated area for online learning.
A total of 164 3rd-year medical students participated in this mandatory disaster and military medicine course during the COVID-19 pandemic. The satisfaction survey response rate was 96.5%. The students were satisfied with the whole curriculum (3.8/5). Most of the free-text comments regarding the course represented a high level of appreciation. The students felt more confident in the knowledge and skills they gained in hands-on exercises than they did in the knowledge and skills they gained in online exercises. The students showed significant improvements in knowledge after the course.
We demonstrated that this adapted hybrid arrangement provided an enhanced learning experience, but we also found that medical students were more confident in their knowledge and skills when they had real hands-on practice.
2019年冠状病毒病(COVID-19)大流行对医学教育的各个方面都产生了重大影响。现代卫生系统必须为各种灾难性场景做好准备,包括新出现的传染病爆发以及人为和自然灾害。在COVID-19大流行期间,虽然传统教学方法的使用有所减少,但基于网络的教学方法的使用却有所增加。COVID-19本身以及随之而来的感染控制措施限制了全面实践。因此,我们开发了一种经过调整的混合模式,该模式保留了足够的实践操作和教育公平性,并将其应用于一群参加军医大学强制性灾害教育课程的本科医学生。
该课程通过指定的灾害应对跨学科模块,涵盖了在紧急情况和创伤场景中使用的技能的获取。在这门一学分的强制性灾害与军事医学教育课程中,使用了几个异步和同步在线网络研讨会。为了提供实践操作机会并确保教育公平,学生被分成15个小组,每组12名学生。实践操作练习也进行了录制,并在指定区域传播给学生以供在线学习。
在COVID-19大流行期间,共有164名三年级医学生参加了这门强制性灾害与军事医学课程。满意度调查的回复率为96.5%。学生对整个课程感到满意(3.8/5)。关于该课程的大多数自由文本评论都表示高度赞赏。学生们对通过实践操作练习获得的知识和技能比通过在线练习获得的知识和技能更有信心。课程结束后,学生们的知识有了显著提高。
我们证明了这种经过调整的混合安排提供了增强的学习体验,但我们也发现,医学生在进行实际实践操作时,对自己的知识和技能更有信心。