IEEE Trans Ultrason Ferroelectr Freq Control. 2019 Sep;66(9):1413-1421. doi: 10.1109/TUFFC.2019.2921925. Epub 2019 Jun 14.
This article evaluated the repeatability and reproducibility (R&R) of quantitative ultrasound (QUS) biomarkers attenuation coefficient (AC) and backscatter coefficient (BSC) in transvaginal QUS reference phantoms for obstetric applications. Five phantoms were scanned by three sonographers according to the scanning protocol. Each sonographer scanned each phantom with four transvaginal transducers of the same model (MC9-4) and three probe cover types (latex cover, nonlatex cover, and no cover). The AC and BSC were estimated by using a reference phantom method. The R&R analysis was performed for the frequency-averaged AC and logBSC (= 10logBSC) (5.4-5.8 MHz) by using three-factor random effects Analysis of Variance with interaction. The total R&R variabilities for AC and logBSC are small (AC: 0.042-0.065 dB/cm-MHz; logBSC: 0.50-0.68 dB), indicating high measurement precision. These values are small compared to the ranges of AC (0.28-0.99 dB/cm-MHz) and logBSC (-33.16 to -20.35 dB) of the five phantoms. The AC and logBSC biomarkers measured on transvaginal QUS phantoms using the reference phantom method are repeatable, and reproducible between sonographers, transducers, and probe covers.
本文评估了定量超声(QUS)生物标志物衰减系数(AC)和反向散射系数(BSC)在用于产科应用的经阴道 QUS 参考体模中的可重复性和再现性(R&R)。根据扫描协议,由三位超声医师对五个体模进行了扫描。每位超声医师使用相同型号(MC9-4)的四个经阴道换能器和三种探头罩类型(乳胶罩、非乳胶罩和无罩)对每个体模进行了扫描。使用参考体模法估算 AC 和 BSC。使用具有交互作用的三因素随机效应方差分析对频率平均 AC 和 logBSC(= 10logBSC)(5.4-5.8 MHz)进行 R&R 分析。AC 和 logBSC 的总 R&R 变异性较小(AC:0.042-0.065 dB/cm-MHz;logBSC:0.50-0.68 dB),表明测量精度高。这些值与五个体模的 AC(0.28-0.99 dB/cm-MHz)和 logBSC(-33.16 至-20.35 dB)范围相比很小。使用参考体模法测量经阴道 QUS 体模上的 AC 和 logBSC 生物标志物具有可重复性,并且在超声医师、换能器和探头罩之间具有再现性。