Lishchynsky Justin T, Rutschmann Trevor D, Toomey Clodagh M, Palacios-Derflingher Luz, Yeates Keith O, Emery Carolyn A, Schneider Kathryn J
Faculty of Kinesiology, Sport Injury Prevention Research Centre, University of Calgary, Calgary, AB, Canada.
School of Allied Health, University of Limerick, Limerick, Ireland.
Front Neurol. 2019 Jun 6;10:588. doi: 10.3389/fneur.2019.00588. eCollection 2019.
Prospective cohort study. The recommendations regarding the optimal amount and type of rest for promoting recovery following concussion are based on expert opinion rather than evidence-based guidelines due to current a lack of high-level studies. There is an evident need for more research into the parameters of rest and activity and its effects on recovery from concussion. To evaluate the association between the amount of moderate and vigorous physical activity (MVPA) during the first 3 days following concussion diagnosis and time to medical clearance (days) to return to play in youth ice hockey players. Thirty youth ice hockey players (12-17 years) that were diagnosed with a concussion sustained during ice hockey were recruited to participate. The exposure was the cumulative amount of MVPA (minutes), measured using a waist-worn Actigraph accelerometer. Participants were dichotomized into high (≥148.5) and low (<148.5) activity groups based on the median of cumulative time spent in MVPA over the first 3 days following injury diagnosis. Participants in both the low and high activity group reported to the clinic at a median time of 4 days post-injury (low activity IQR: 3-5 days; high activity IQR: 3-7 days). The low activity group completed a median time of 110.7 min (IQR: 76.2-131.0 min) in MVPA, whereas the high activity had a median of 217.2 min (IQR 184.2-265.2 min) in MVPA. Kaplan Meier survival curves with Log-rank tests of hypothesis revealed the high activity group took significantly more time to be medically cleared to return to play ( = 0.041) compared to the low activity group. The results from this study suggest that more time in MVPA early in the recovery period may result in a greater time to medical clearance to return to full participation in ice hockey. Future research, using valid measures of activity, are required to better understand the relationship between early activity and recovery following concussion in youth.
前瞻性队列研究。由于目前缺乏高水平研究,关于脑震荡后促进恢复的最佳休息量和类型的建议是基于专家意见而非循证指南。显然需要对休息和活动的参数及其对脑震荡恢复的影响进行更多研究。为了评估青少年冰球运动员在脑震荡诊断后的前3天内中等强度和剧烈身体活动(MVPA)量与恢复比赛的医疗许可时间(天数)之间的关联。招募了30名被诊断为在冰球运动中遭受脑震荡的青少年冰球运动员(12 - 17岁)参与研究。暴露因素是使用佩戴在腰部的活动记录仪加速度计测量的MVPA累计量(分钟)。根据受伤诊断后前3天MVPA累计时间的中位数,将参与者分为高活动量组(≥148.5)和低活动量组(<148.5)。低活动量组和高活动量组的参与者在受伤后中位时间4天到诊所报到(低活动量组四分位间距:3 - 5天;高活动量组四分位间距:3 - 7天)。低活动量组在MVPA中的中位时间为110.7分钟(四分位间距:76.2 - 131.0分钟),而高活动量组在MVPA中的中位数为217.2分钟(四分位间距184.2 - 265.2分钟)。采用对数秩检验假设的Kaplan Meier生存曲线显示,与低活动量组相比,高活动量组获得恢复比赛的医疗许可所需时间显著更长(P = 0.041)。本研究结果表明,恢复早期MVPA时间增加可能导致获得恢复全面参与冰球比赛的医疗许可时间延长。未来需要使用有效的活动测量方法进行研究,以更好地理解青少年脑震荡后早期活动与恢复之间的关系。