Assistant professor, Frederick S. Pardee School of Global Studies, Boston University, Boston, MA, USA.
Senior researcher, Ipas, Chapel Hill, NC, USA.
Int Perspect Sex Reprod Health. 2018 Dec 1;44(4):133-145. doi: 10.1363/44e6918.
Ethnic and linguistic concordance are important dimensions of the patient-physician relationship, and are linked to health care disparities. However, evidence on the associations between health behavior and outcomes and patient-provider concordance is limited, especially in low- and middle-income settings.
To examine how concordance between women and their primary health midwife is associated with women's receipt of postpartum IUD counseling, observational data from a cluster-randomized trial assessing an intervention to increase postpartum IUD counseling were used. Data on 4,497 women who delivered at six hospitals in Sri Lanka between September 2015 and March 2017 were merged with data on 245 primary health midwives, and indicators of linguistic concordance, ethnic concordance and their interaction were generated. Multivariate logistic regression analyses were used to assess the associations between concordance and women's receipt of counseling.
Women from non-Sinhalese groups in Sri Lanka face disparities in the receipt of postpartum IUD counseling. Compared with the ethnolinguistic majority (Sinhalese women who speak only Sinhala), non-Sinhalese women have lower odds of having received postpartum IUD counseling, whether they speak both Sinhala and Tamil (odds ratio, 0.6) or only Tamil (0.5). Ethnic discordance- rather than linguistic discordance-is the primary driver of this disparity.
The findings highlight the need for interventions that aim to bridge the sociocultural gaps between providers and patients. Matching women and their providers on ethnolinguistic background may help to reduce disparities in care.
种族和语言的一致性是医患关系的重要维度,与医疗保健差距有关。然而,关于健康行为和结果与患者-提供者一致性之间的关联的证据有限,尤其是在中低收入环境中。
为了研究女性与其主要的初级保健助产士之间的一致性如何与女性接受产后宫内节育器咨询相关,我们使用了一项评估增加产后宫内节育器咨询干预措施的集群随机试验的观察数据。将 2015 年 9 月至 2017 年 3 月在斯里兰卡六家医院分娩的 4497 名妇女的数据与 245 名初级保健助产士的数据合并,并生成语言一致性、种族一致性及其相互作用的指标。使用多变量逻辑回归分析来评估一致性与妇女接受咨询之间的关联。
在斯里兰卡,来自非僧伽罗族群体的女性在接受产后宫内节育器咨询方面存在差异。与僧伽罗族(只说僧伽罗语的女性)的主要语言群体相比,非僧伽罗族女性接受产后宫内节育器咨询的可能性较低,无论是说僧伽罗语和泰米尔语(比值比,0.6)还是只说泰米尔语(0.5)。造成这种差异的主要原因是种族不和谐,而不是语言不和谐。
这些发现强调了需要采取干预措施,旨在弥合提供者和患者之间的社会文化差距。根据种族和语言背景匹配女性和其提供者可能有助于减少护理差距。