Department of Medical Modeling, Simulation, and Mission Support, Naval Health Research Center, 140 Sylvester Road, San Diego, CA 92106-3521.
Leidos Inc., 10260 Campus Point Dr, San Diego, CA 92121.
Mil Med. 2020 Feb 12;185(1-2):e244-e253. doi: 10.1093/milmed/usz149.
Little population-based research has described the transition from Department of Defense (DoD) to Department of Veterans Affairs (VA) healthcare following combat related amputations. The objectives were to describe (1) to what extent patients used either DoD only facilities, both DoD and VA facilities, or VA only facilities during the first 5 years postinjury, (2) which specific clinics were used and (3) clinic use among patients with different levels of amputation (upper versus lower), and among patients with early or late amputation.
This was a retrospective analysis of health data extracted from the expeditionary medical encounter database (EMED) and national DoD and VA databases. Patients were 649 US service members who sustained a single major limb amputation following injuries in the Iraq and Afghanistan conflicts, 2001-2008. We compared yearly DoD and VA clinic use by patient groups with different levels of amputation (upper limb: above versus below elbow or lower limb: above versus below knee), different timing of amputation (early: within 90 days postinjury versus late: more than 90 days postinjury), military component (Active Duty versus National Guard/Reserve) and race (White versus Black). For all groups, we calculated the percentage of patients using: (1) DoD only, (2) both DoD and VA or 3) VA only clinics during each of postinjury years 1 through 5. We also calculated the percentage of patients who used specific clinics (e.g., social work, prosthetics, mental health) during each postinjury year.
During postinjury year 1, over 98% of patients used DoD only or both DoD and VA clinics. Most individuals (70% to 78%) used both DoD and VA clinics during postinjury year 1. Use of VA only clinics increased gradually between postinjury year 2 (15% to 30% of patient groups) and year 5 (75% to 88%). This gradual transition to use of VA only clinics was seen consistently across patient groups with different anatomical levels or timing of amputation, military component or race. Patients with lower levels of amputation (versus higher levels) and individuals with early amputations (versus late) transitioned earlier to VA only care. Overall, clinic use was high as 91% to 100% of all patient groups used one or more clinics (DoD or VA) during each of the first 5 years. For specific clinics, most patients used DoD facilities related to rehabilitation (physical therapy, prosthetics) or transitional care (social work) particularly during postinjury year 1. Use of most VA clinics studied (social work, primary care, prosthetics, mental health) showed a modest increase primarily after postinjury year 1 and remained stable through postinjury year 5. The results indicated apparent underuse of psychiatric/mental health and prosthetics between postinjury year 1 and 2.
The present study indicated a gradual transition from DoD to VA only healthcare which extended across 5 years following combat related amputations. Patients with lower levels of amputation or early amputation generally transitioned earlier to VA only healthcare. These results can inform medical planning to support a timely and clinically effective transition from DoD to VA healthcare.
鲜有基于人群的研究描述过与战斗相关的截肢后从国防部(DoD)到退伍军人事务部(VA)医疗保健的转变。目的是描述:(1)在受伤后的前 5 年内,患者在多大程度上仅使用 DoD 设施、DoD 和 VA 设施或仅使用 VA 设施;(2)使用了哪些特定诊所;(3)在不同截肢水平(上肢与下肢)和不同截肢时间(早期与晚期)的患者中,诊所的使用情况。
这是对从远征医疗遭遇数据库(EMED)和国家 DoD 和 VA 数据库中提取的健康数据进行的回顾性分析。患者为 2001 年至 2008 年间在伊拉克和阿富汗冲突中因受伤而导致单一大肢截肢的 649 名美国军人。我们比较了不同截肢水平(上肢:肘上或肘下;下肢:膝上或膝下)、不同截肢时间(早期:伤后 90 天内;晚期:伤后 90 天以上)、军事组成部分(现役军人与国民警卫队/预备役)和种族(白人与黑人)的患者群体的每年 DoD 和 VA 诊所使用情况。对于所有群体,我们计算了以下百分比:(1)仅使用 DoD;(2)同时使用 DoD 和 VA;(3)仅使用 VA 诊所。我们还计算了每个受伤后年份使用特定诊所(例如,社会工作、假肢、心理健康)的患者百分比。
在受伤后的第一年,超过 98%的患者仅使用 DoD 或 DoD 和 VA 诊所。大多数患者(70%至 78%)在受伤后第一年同时使用 DoD 和 VA 诊所。在受伤后第二年(15%至 30%的患者群体)和第五年(75%至 88%),使用 VA 仅诊所的比例逐渐增加。这种向仅使用 VA 诊所的逐渐转变在不同解剖水平或截肢时间、军事组成部分或种族的患者群体中是一致的。较低水平截肢(与较高水平相比)和早期截肢(与晚期相比)的患者更早过渡到仅 VA 护理。总体而言,91%至 100%的所有患者群体在受伤后的前 5 年期间都使用了一个或多个诊所(DoD 或 VA)。对于特定的诊所,大多数患者使用与康复(物理治疗、假肢)或过渡护理(社会工作)相关的 DoD 设施,特别是在受伤后的第一年。研究的大多数 VA 诊所(社会工作、初级保健、假肢、心理健康)的使用量都有所增加,主要是在受伤后的第一年之后,并且在受伤后的第五年保持稳定。结果表明,在受伤后的第一年和第二年之间,精神病/心理健康和假肢的使用明显不足。
本研究表明,与战斗相关的截肢后,从 DoD 向仅 VA 医疗保健的转变是逐渐发生的,时间跨度为 5 年。较低水平截肢或早期截肢的患者通常更早过渡到仅 VA 医疗保健。这些结果可以为医疗规划提供信息,以支持从 DoD 向 VA 医疗保健的及时和临床有效的过渡。