Department of Medical Education, The Icahn School of Medicine at Mount Sinai, New York City, NY, US.
Department of Medicine, The Icahn School of Medicine at Mount Sinai, New York City, NY, US.
Ann Glob Health. 2019 Jun 26;85(1):92. doi: 10.5334/aogh.2465.
The number of global health opportunities offered to medical students has increased over the past 20 years. Recognizing the growing prevalence of these experiences, a number of studies have shown that these types of exposures have a significant impact on medical students' education. However, there is a paucity of literature on the educational impacts of short-term domestic service-learning trips, which can be more accessible due to fewer logistical and financial barriers. This mixed-methods qualitative/quantitative study aims to understand the impact of a domestic one-week service learning program on medical students' educational development and career choices.
The authors conducted a qualitative analysis of journal entries written by a cohort of students during a domestic weeklong service trip. They also administered a survey to all students who had participated in the program between 2009-2016.
In 88.6% (n = 31) of the journal entries, students reported learning about border town life, Native American health, and rural medical practice. In 42.8% (n = 15) of entries, participants described experiences they felt would impact their future medical career decisions. The students' reflections also revealed implicit benefits such as becoming aware of privilege within society (n = 14, 40.0%). The majority of survey respondents reported that the trip improved their medical education and influenced the field and location of their future/current practice.
This study suggests that domestic short-term service-learning trips impact medical students' immediate educational development and may influence their future career plans. Further investigation into the local community's perceptions of this service-learning trip will provide greater understanding of the impact on all involved.
在过去的 20 年中,向医学生提供的全球健康机会的数量有所增加。认识到这些经验越来越普遍,许多研究表明,这些类型的经历对医学生的教育有重大影响。然而,由于短期国内服务学习旅行的后勤和财务障碍较少,因此关于短期国内服务学习旅行对医学生教育发展和职业选择的影响的文献很少。本混合方法定性/定量研究旨在了解为期一周的国内服务学习计划对医学生教育发展和职业选择的影响。
作者对一组学生在国内一周服务旅行期间写的日记进行了定性分析。他们还对所有参加过 2009-2016 年期间该项目的学生进行了调查。
在 88.6%(n=31)的日记中,学生报告了解边境城镇生活、美国原住民健康和农村医疗实践。在 42.8%(n=15)的条目,参与者描述了他们认为会影响他们未来医疗职业决策的经历。学生的反思还揭示了一些隐性收益,例如意识到社会中的特权(n=14,40.0%)。大多数调查受访者报告说,这次旅行改善了他们的医学教育,并影响了他们未来/当前实践的领域和地点。
这项研究表明,国内短期服务学习旅行会影响医学生的即时教育发展,并可能影响他们未来的职业计划。进一步调查当地社区对这种服务学习旅行的看法,将有助于更好地了解所有相关方的影响。