The University of British Columbia, Canada.
Med Teach. 2010;32(12):977-82. doi: 10.3109/01421590903394579.
Medical students are expressing increasing interest in international experiences in low-income countries where there are pronounced inequities in health and socio-economic development.
We carried out a detailed exploration of the international service-learning (ISL) experience of three medical students and the value of critical reflection as a pedagogical approach to enhance medical students' conceptions of the Canadian Medical Education Directions for Specialists (CanMEDS) Health Advocate Role.
A phenomenological approach enabled us to study in considerable depth the students' experience from their perspective. Students kept reflective journals and wrote essays including detailed accounts of their experiences. The content of the students' journals and essays was analyzed using the critical incident technique.
Students noted an increasingly meaningful sense of what it means to be vulnerable and marginalized, a heightened level of awareness of the social determinants of health and the related importance of community engagement, and a deeper appreciation of the health advocate role and key concepts embedded within it.
This in-depth phenomenological study focused on the detailed experiences of three students from whom we learned that social justice-oriented approaches to service-learning, coupled with critical reflection, provide potentially viable pedagogical approaches for learning the health advocate role. How this experience will affect the students' future medical practice is yet unknown.
越来越多的医学生对在低收入国家开展国际体验活动表现出浓厚的兴趣,这些国家在健康和社会经济发展方面存在明显的不平等。
我们详细探讨了 3 名医学生的国际服务学习(ISL)经历,以及批判性反思作为一种教学方法的价值,以增强医学生对加拿大医学教育专家方向(CanMEDS)健康倡导者角色的概念理解。
现象学方法使我们能够从学生的角度深入研究他们的体验。学生们写了反思日志和论文,包括对自己经历的详细描述。学生日志和论文的内容使用关键事件技术进行了分析。
学生们注意到,他们对弱势和边缘化意味着什么有了越来越深刻的认识,对健康的社会决定因素以及与之相关的社区参与的重要性有了更高的认识,对健康倡导者的角色及其内在的关键概念有了更深入的理解。
这项深入的现象学研究聚焦于 3 名学生的详细经历,我们从中了解到,以社会正义为导向的服务学习方法加上批判性反思,为学习健康倡导者角色提供了潜在可行的教学方法。这种经历将如何影响学生未来的医疗实践尚不清楚。