Mannarino Pietro, Matta Thiago, Lima Jefferson, Simão Roberto, Freitas de Salles Belmiro
Department of Orthopedic Surgery, Clementino Fraga Filho University Hospital, Federal University of Rio de Janeiro (UFRJ), Rio de Janeiro, Brazil.
Biomedical Engineering Program, UFRJ, Rio de Janeiro, Brazil ; and.
J Strength Cond Res. 2021 Oct 1;35(10):2677-2681. doi: 10.1519/JSC.0000000000003234.
Mannarino, P, Matta, T, Lima, J, Simão, R, and Freitas de Salles, B. Single-Joint Exercise Results in Higher Hypertrophy of Elbow Flexors Than Multijoint Exercise. J Strength Cond Res 35(10): 2677-2681, 2021-Recent data suggest that single-joint exercises are unnecessary to maximize the resistance training (RT) results in novice to advanced individuals. However, the present literature is still inconsistent on this topic and controversy arises. The aim of this study was to compare the effects of the unilateral dumbbell row (DR) (multiple-joint) vs. unilateral biceps curl (BC) (single-joint) exercises on strength and elbow flexors muscle thickness (MT). Ten untrained men were assigned to an 8-week RT program for elbow flexors, one arm performing DR and the other performing BC in a within-subject design. After a familiarization, pretraining MT was measured using an ultrasound (US) technique, and strength was tested using 10 repetition maximum (10RM) tests. After pretesting, 8 weeks of RT (4-6 sets, 8-12 repetitions to concentric failure, 2 sessions per week) was performed. Post-testing was conducted in the same order as pretesting 48 and 72 hours after the last session. Single-joint BC exercise resulted in higher hypertrophy of elbow flexors (11.06%) than the DR (5.16%) multijoint exercise after 8 weeks of RT (p = 0.009). The 10RM improvement was higher for DR in DR-trained arm, whereas 10RM for BC was higher in BC-trained arm. The single-joint exercise resulted in higher hypertrophy of the elbow flexors than multijoint exercise after 8 weeks of RT, whereas strength improvements were greater in accordance with specificity of RT exercise. Therefore, in RT prescription for elbow flexors hypertrophy, single-joint exercises such as BC should be emphasized.
曼纳里诺、P、马塔、T、利马、J、西芒、R和弗雷塔斯·德·萨莱斯、B。单关节运动比多关节运动更能使肘屈肌产生更大的肥大。《力量与体能研究杂志》35(10): 2677 - 2681, 2021 - 近期数据表明,对于新手到进阶者而言,单关节运动对于最大化抗阻训练(RT)效果并非必要。然而,目前的文献在这个问题上仍然不一致,争议由此产生。本研究的目的是比较单侧哑铃划船(DR)(多关节)与单侧肱二头肌弯举(BC)(单关节)运动对力量和肘屈肌肌肉厚度(MT)的影响。十名未经训练的男性被分配到一个为期8周的肘屈肌RT计划中,采用受试者内设计,一只手臂进行DR,另一只手臂进行BC。在熟悉训练后,使用超声(US)技术测量训练前的MT,并使用10次重复最大值(10RM)测试来测试力量。预测试后,进行8周的RT(4 - 6组,向心收缩至力竭8 - 12次重复,每周2次训练)。在最后一次训练后48小时和72小时按照与预测试相同的顺序进行后测试。经过8周的RT后,单关节BC运动导致肘屈肌的肥大(11.06%)高于DR(5.16%)多关节运动(p = 0.009)。在进行DR训练的手臂中,DR的10RM提高幅度更大,而在进行BC训练的手臂中,BC的10RM更高。经过8周的RT后,单关节运动比多关节运动导致肘屈肌产生更大的肥大,而力量的提高根据RT运动的特异性更大。因此,在针对肘屈肌肥大的RT处方中,应强调诸如BC这样的单关节运动。