Nuri Nazmun Nahar, Sarker Malabika, Ahmed Helal Uddin, Hossain Mohammad Didar, Beiersmann Claudia, Jahn Albrecht
1Institute of Public Health, Ruprecht-Karls-Universität Heidelberg, INF 130/3, 69120 Heidelberg, Germany.
2James P. Grant School of Public Health, BRAC University, 66 Mohakhali, Dhaka, 1212 Bangladesh.
Int J Ment Health Syst. 2019 Jun 22;13:46. doi: 10.1186/s13033-019-0303-x. eCollection 2019.
A person's perception of health service quality depends on his or her expectations and priorities. If the perception of care is good, then it eventually enhances future health service utilization, adherence to treatment and desired outcomes. Understanding a patient's perspective is key for delivering a better quality patient-centred health care service. This study explored experience and perception of patients and their attendants of mental health care services at the National Institute of Mental Health (NIMH) which is the only national level mental health institute in Bangladesh. NIMH is located in the capital city and provides specialized mental health care services for the whole population.
A facility-based cross-sectional study was conducted using a mixed-method design at the NIMH. A total of 40 respondents (patients, or their attendants if the patient was minor or unable to respond due to lack of mental stability) visiting the outpatient department (OPD) of NIMH were selected by purposive sampling. For each of the ten ICD 10 categories (10th revision of International Classification of Diseases by the World Health Organization [WHO]) for mental disorders, four patients were chosen. Finally, 13 patients and 27 attendants (on behalf of 17 minor patients and 10 adult patients unable to respond) participated in the interview.
The respondents rated 34 short statements clustered around four dimensions of care (accessibility, interpersonal communications, condition of the waiting and consultation rooms, and general quality of OPD services) and we interpreted those scores as follows: 7.6-10 very satisfied/very good quality, 5.1-7.5 satisfied/good quality, 2.6-5.0 dissatisfied/poor quality and 1.0-2.5 completely dissatisfied/very poor quality. For accessibility and interpersonal communications, the patients perceived care as very good (average scores on a Likert scale of 1-10 were 8.3 and 7.6, respectively). The respondents considered the condition of the waiting and consultation rooms and general quality of OPD care as good (average scores 5.8 and 7.1, respectively). NIMH had serious lack of resources in terms of functional medical equipment and physicians appointed, which negatively impacted on the service quality.
Patients receiving services from the NIMH OPD had a positive perception of the quality of care in general. But, at an individual level, some respondents expressed dissatisfaction. Our findings are informative for quality improvement and client-oriented care service planning at NIMH, Bangladesh.
一个人对医疗服务质量的认知取决于其期望和优先事项。如果对护理的认知良好,那么最终会提高未来医疗服务的利用率、治疗依从性和预期结果。了解患者的观点是提供更高质量的以患者为中心的医疗服务的关键。本研究探讨了孟加拉国唯一的国家级精神卫生机构——国家精神卫生研究所(NIMH)的患者及其陪护人员对精神卫生保健服务的体验和认知。NIMH位于首都,为全体民众提供专业的精神卫生保健服务。
在NIMH采用混合方法设计进行了一项基于机构的横断面研究。通过目的抽样法,从NIMH门诊部(OPD)选取了40名受访者(患者,或如果患者是未成年人或因精神不稳定无法回应,则为其陪护人员)。对于世界卫生组织(WHO)《国际疾病分类》第10版(ICD 10)中的十类精神障碍,每类选取4名患者。最后,13名患者和27名陪护人员(代表17名未成年患者和10名无法回应的成年患者)参与了访谈。
受访者对围绕护理四个维度(可及性、人际沟通、候诊室和咨询室状况以及OPD服务的总体质量)的34条简短陈述进行了评分,我们对这些分数的解读如下:7.6 - 10分表示非常满意/质量非常好,5.1 - 7.5分表示满意/质量好,2.6 - 5.0分表示不满意/质量差,1.0 - 2.5分表示完全不满意/质量非常差。对于可及性和人际沟通,患者认为护理非常好(李克特量表1 - 10分的平均得分分别为8.3和7.6)。受访者认为候诊室和咨询室状况以及OPD护理的总体质量良好(平均得分分别为5.8和7.1)。NIMH在功能性医疗设备和指定医生方面严重缺乏资源,这对服务质量产生了负面影响。
从NIMH OPD接受服务的患者总体上对护理质量有积极的认知。但是,在个体层面,一些受访者表达了不满。我们的研究结果为孟加拉国NIMH的质量改进和以客户为导向的护理服务规划提供了信息。