Zhao Beiqun, Lam Jenny, Hollandsworth Hannah M, Lee Arielle M, Lopez Nicole E, Abbadessa Benjamin, Eisenstein Samuel, Cosman Bard C, Ramamoorthy Sonia L, Parry Lisa A
Department of Surgery, University of California, San Diego, 9300 Campus Point Drive, Mail Code 7220, La Jolla, CA, 92037, USA.
Surg Endosc. 2020 Apr;34(4):1712-1721. doi: 10.1007/s00464-019-06954-0. Epub 2019 Jul 8.
The use of the surgical robot has increased annually since its introduction, especially in general surgery. Despite the tremendous increase in utilization, there are currently no validated curricula to train residents in robotic surgery, and the effects of robotic surgery on general surgery residency training are not well defined. In this study, we aim to explore the perceptions of resident and attending surgeons toward robotic surgery education in general surgery residency training.
We performed a qualitative thematic analysis of in-person, one-on-one, semi-structured interviews with general surgery residents and attending surgeons at a large academic health system. Convenient and purposeful sampling was performed in order to ensure diverse demographics, experiences, and opinions were represented. Data were analyzed continuously, and interviews were conducted until thematic saturation was reached, which occurred after 20 residents and seven attendings.
All interviewees agreed that dual consoles are necessary to maximize the teaching potential of the robotic platform, and the importance of simulation and simulators in robotic surgery education is paramount. However, further work to ensure proper access to simulation resources for residents is necessary. While most recognize that bedside-assist skills are essential, most think its educational value plateaus quickly. Lastly, residents believe that earlier exposure to robotic surgery is necessary and that almost every case has a portion that is level-appropriate for residents to perform on the robot.
As robotic surgery transitions from novelty to ubiquity, the importance of effective general surgery robotic surgery training during residency is paramount. Through in-depth interviews, this study provides examples of effective educational tools and techniques, highlights the importance of simulation, and explores opinions regarding the role of the resident in robotic surgery education. We hope the insights gained from this study can be used to develop and/or refine robotic surgery curricula.
自手术机器人问世以来,其使用量逐年增加,尤其是在普通外科领域。尽管其使用量大幅增长,但目前尚无经过验证的课程来培训住院医师进行机器人手术,而且机器人手术对普通外科住院医师培训的影响也尚未明确界定。在本研究中,我们旨在探讨住院医师和主治外科医生对普通外科住院医师培训中机器人手术教育的看法。
我们对一家大型学术医疗系统的普通外科住院医师和主治外科医生进行了面对面、一对一的半结构化访谈,并进行了定性主题分析。采用方便抽样和目的抽样,以确保涵盖不同的人口统计学特征、经验和观点。对数据进行持续分析,访谈持续进行直至达到主题饱和,即采访了20名住院医师和7名主治医生后达到饱和。
所有受访者都认为,双控制台对于最大限度发挥机器人平台的教学潜力是必要的,并且模拟和模拟器在机器人手术教育中的重要性至关重要。然而,有必要进一步努力确保住院医师能够适当使用模拟资源。虽然大多数人认识到床边辅助技能至关重要,但大多数人认为其教育价值很快就会达到平台期。最后,住院医师认为有必要更早接触机器人手术,并且几乎每个病例都有一部分适合住院医师在机器人上操作的难度级别。
随着机器人手术从新奇事物转变为普遍应用,住院期间有效的普通外科机器人手术培训至关重要。通过深入访谈,本研究提供了有效教育工具和技术的示例,强调了模拟的重要性,并探讨了关于住院医师在机器人手术教育中的作用的观点。我们希望从本研究中获得的见解可用于开发和/或完善机器人手术课程。