McPake M
School of Health and Life Sciences, Glasgow Caledonian University, Cowcaddens Road, Glasgow G4 0BA, UK.
Radiography (Lond). 2019 Aug;25(3):220-226. doi: 10.1016/j.radi.2019.01.008. Epub 2019 Feb 5.
A three-phased, mixed-methods study was conducted to explore the experiences of undergraduate radiotherapy students and their supervising practice educators within U.K. radiotherapy practice placement.
Qualitative data were gathered from focus groups/interviews with volunteer participants to elicit in-depth perceptions about experiences of practice placement. Data were transcribed, verbatim, and manually coded and analysed by the researcher using the applied research methodology of framework analysis, enabling the investigation of the a priori theme 'practice placement model', and recommendations were made for improvement.
Two radiotherapy placement models are confirmed, i.e. the single student model, and the paired student model, and advantages and disadvantages are identified for each. Study findings suggest that neither radiotherapy model is superior to the other in terms of placement education and experience. Previous and current experience of either model appears to bias students and practice educators towards that model, despite recognition of its disadvantages.
The experiences of students and practice educators using the radiotherapy models are consistent with the experiences of other AHPs and nursing using similar practice placement models. It is recommended that all students should have access to peer-assisted learning on placement to improve critical thinking skills, to enable time for reflection, and to consolidate learning.
开展了一项分三个阶段的混合方法研究,以探索英国放射治疗专业本科学生及其临床实习指导教师在放射治疗临床实习中的经历。
通过与志愿者参与者进行焦点小组讨论/访谈收集定性数据,以深入了解临床实习经历。数据逐字转录,由研究人员使用框架分析的应用研究方法进行手动编码和分析,从而对先验主题“临床实习模式”进行调查,并提出改进建议。
确认了两种放射治疗临床实习模式,即单学生模式和双学生模式,并确定了每种模式的优缺点。研究结果表明,就临床实习教育和经历而言,两种放射治疗模式都不优于另一种。尽管认识到其缺点,但无论是哪种模式的既往和当前经历似乎都会使学生和临床实习指导教师倾向于该模式。
使用放射治疗模式的学生和临床实习指导教师的经历与其他健康和社会照护专业人员及护理人员使用类似临床实习模式的经历一致。建议所有学生在实习期间都应有机会接受同伴辅助学习,以提高批判性思维能力,留出反思时间,并巩固学习成果。