Graduate School of Education, Hiroshima University, Hiroshima, Japan.
Hiroshima Bunkyo Women's University, Hiroshima, Japan.
Neuroimage. 2019 Nov 1;201:116015. doi: 10.1016/j.neuroimage.2019.116015. Epub 2019 Jul 12.
Our personal internal preferences while making decisions are usually consistent. Recent psychological studies, however, show observable variability of internal criteria occurs by random noise. The neural correlates of said random noise - an instance of 'psychological noise' - yet remain unclear. Combining simulation, behavioral, and neural approaches, our study investigated the psychological and neural correlates of such random noise in our internal criteria during decision making. We applied well-established decision-making tasks which relied on either internal criteria - occupation choice task as internally-guided decision making (IDM) - or external criteria - salary judgment task as externally-guided decision making (EDM). Subjects underwent EEG for resting state and task-evoked activity during IDM and EDM. We measured resting state long-range temporal correlation (LRTC) in the alpha frequency range as the index of neuronal noise. Based on our simulation, we identified a measure of psychological noise (as distinguished from true preference change) in IDM. The main finding shows that the indices for psychological noise are directly related to frontocentral LRTC in the alpha range. Higher degrees of frontocentral LRTC, which index lower neuronal noise, were related to lower degrees of psychological noise during IDM. This was not found during EDM. Resting state LRTC was also related to task-evoked activity, such as conflict-related negativity, during IDM only. Taken together, our data demonstrate, for the first time, the direct relationship between neuronal noise in the brain's intrinsic activity and psychological noise in the internal criteria of our decision making.
在做决策时,我们个人的内部偏好通常是一致的。然而,最近的心理学研究表明,内部标准会因随机噪声而发生可观察到的变化。这种随机噪声的神经相关物——即“心理噪声”的一个实例——仍然不清楚。我们结合模拟、行为和神经方法,研究了我们在决策过程中内部标准中这种随机噪声的心理和神经相关性。我们应用了成熟的决策任务,这些任务依赖于内部标准——职业选择任务作为内部引导决策(IDM)——或外部标准——工资判断任务作为外部引导决策(EDM)。在 IDM 和 EDM 期间,受试者接受了 EEG 静息状态和任务诱发活动。我们测量了静息状态下的长程时间相关(LRTC),作为神经元噪声的指标,其范围在 alpha 频率内。基于我们的模拟,我们在 IDM 中确定了一个用于区分心理噪声(与真实偏好变化区分开)的指标。主要发现表明,心理噪声的指标与 alpha 频段中的额中央 LRTC 直接相关。额中央 LRTC 程度较高,表明神经元噪声较低,与 IDM 期间心理噪声程度较低有关。在 EDM 中则没有发现这种情况。静息状态 LRTC 还与任务诱发活动有关,例如 IDM 期间的冲突相关负波。总的来说,我们的数据首次证明了大脑内在活动中的神经元噪声与我们决策内部标准中的心理噪声之间的直接关系。