Department of Medical Physics, Graduate School of Medicine, Tokyo Women's Medical University, 8-1, Kawadacho, Shinjuku-ku, Tokyo 162-8666, Japan. Author to whom any correspondence should be addressed.
Phys Med Biol. 2019 Sep 4;64(17):175011. doi: 10.1088/1361-6560/ab3276.
Positron emission tomography (PET) has been extensively studied and clinically investigated for dose verification in proton therapy. However, the production distributions of positron emitters are not proportional to the dose distribution. Thus, direct dose evaluation is limited when using the conventional PET-based approach. We propose a method for estimating the dose distribution from the positron emitter distributions using the maximum likelihood (ML) expectation maximization (EM) algorithm combined with filtering. In experiments to verify the effectiveness of the proposed method, mono-energetic and spread-out Bragg-peak proton beams were delivered by a synchrotron, and a water target was irradiated at clinical dose levels. Planar PET measurements were performed during beam pauses and after irradiation over a total period of 200 s. In addition, we conducted a Monte Carlo simulation to obtain the required filter functions and analyze the influence of the number of algorithm iterations on estimation. We successfully estimated the 2D dose distributions even under statistical noise in the PET images. The accuracy of the 2D dose estimation was about 10% for both beams at the 1-[Formula: see text] values of relative error. This value is comparable to the deviations in the measured PET activity distributions. For the laterally integrated profile along the beam direction, a low error within 5% was obtained per irradiation value. Moreover, the difference of estimated proton ranges was within 1 mm, and 2D estimation from the PET images was completed in 21 ms. Hence, the proposed algorithm may be applied to real-time dose monitoring. Although this is the first attempt to use the ML-EM algorithm for dose estimation, the proposed method showed high accuracy and speed in the estimation of proton dose distribution from PET data. The proposed method is thus a step forward to exploit the full potential of PET for in vivo dose verification.
正电子发射断层扫描(PET)已在质子治疗中进行了广泛的研究和临床研究,以进行剂量验证。然而,正电子发射体的产生分布与剂量分布不成比例。因此,当使用传统的基于 PET 的方法时,直接剂量评估受到限制。我们提出了一种使用最大似然(ML)期望最大化(EM)算法结合滤波从正电子发射体分布估计剂量分布的方法。在验证所提出方法有效性的实验中,单能和扩展布拉格峰质子束由同步加速器输送,并且在临床剂量水平下辐照水靶。在总时间为 200 s 的束暂停期间和辐照后进行了平面 PET 测量。此外,我们进行了蒙特卡罗模拟以获得所需的滤波器函数,并分析了算法迭代次数对估计的影响。我们成功地在 PET 图像中的统计噪声下估计了二维剂量分布。在相对误差为 1-[Formula: see text]的值下,两种束的二维剂量估计的精度均约为 10%。该值与测量的 PET 活性分布的偏差相当。对于沿束方向的横向积分轮廓,每个辐照值的误差均小于 5%。此外,估计的质子射程的差异在 1 毫米以内,并且从 PET 图像完成二维估计仅需 21 毫秒。因此,该算法可应用于实时剂量监测。尽管这是首次尝试使用 ML-EM 算法进行剂量估计,但所提出的方法在从 PET 数据估计质子剂量分布方面表现出了很高的准确性和速度。因此,该方法是充分利用 PET 进行体内剂量验证的重要一步。