Mingolla Carla, Hudders Liselot, Vanwesenbeeck Ini, Claerebout Edwin
University of Ghent, 9000, Ghent, Belgium.
Prev Vet Med. 2019 Aug 1;169:104695. doi: 10.1016/j.prevetmed.2019.104695. Epub 2019 May 21.
Resistance against macrocyclic lactones is emerging in Psoroptes ovis mites, the cause of psoroptic mange in sheep and cattle. Therefore, sustainable mange control approaches should be implemented to prevent or slow down resistance. To ensure a proper implementation of such approaches, it is crucial to understand the factors that may impede or facilitate adoption of these practices among farmers. A conceptual model that combines insights from the Theory of Planned Behaviour (TPB, Ajzen, 1991) - a theory that predicts human behaviour -, with insights from behavioural economics (Camerer, 2004; Samson, 2016) - a theory that assumes that behavioural biases or reasoning errors are pervasive in decision-making -, was developed to predict farmers' adoption intention. In particular, this paper examines how behavioural economics can influence farmers' beliefs related to sustainable mange control and through which pathways these biased beliefs can predict adoption intention. A cross-sectional survey study amongst 174 Belgian Blue cattle farmers has been conducted and Structural Equation Modelling was used for analyses. In particular, the model shows that farmers' positive attitudes towards a sustainable mange control method (attitude) and their perceptions of how others evaluate the sustainable control methods (subjective norms) more strongly predict adoption intention than perceived behavioural control. Additionally, the model shows that adoption intention is explained by the bandwagon bias -the belief that other farmers have a positive opinion about the control method-, and availability bias - farmers who have the belief that mange occurs often on their farm - through the determinants of TPB. Although this bandwagon bias influences farmers adoption intention, the rather low presence of availability bias might explain why adoption intention of a sustainable mange control method is limited. Next, retaining to the default treatment (default bias) influences farmers' belief that they are capable of implementing control methods on their farm (perceived behavioural control), while the belief that implementing a control method is perceived as a cost for their farm rather than being beneficial (loss aversion bias) negatively influences attitude and perceived behavioural control. We further discuss important implications that can incite farmers' adoption intention.
绵羊和牛患疥螨病的病原体绵羊痒螨对大环内酯类药物的耐药性正在出现。因此,应实施可持续的疥螨病控制方法,以预防或减缓耐药性的产生。为确保此类方法的正确实施,了解可能阻碍或促进农民采用这些做法的因素至关重要。一个概念模型结合了计划行为理论(TPB,阿杰恩,1991年)——一种预测人类行为的理论——和行为经济学的见解(卡梅勒,2004年;萨姆森,2016年)——一种假设行为偏差或推理错误在决策中普遍存在的理论——来预测农民的采用意愿。特别是,本文研究了行为经济学如何影响农民与可持续疥螨病控制相关的信念,以及这些有偏差的信念通过哪些途径可以预测采用意愿。对174名比利时蓝牛养殖户进行了横断面调查研究,并采用结构方程模型进行分析。具体而言,该模型表明,农民对可持续疥螨病控制方法的积极态度(态度)以及他们对他人如何评价可持续控制方法的看法(主观规范)比感知行为控制更能强烈预测采用意愿。此外,该模型表明,采用意愿可以通过从众偏差——即认为其他农民对控制方法有积极看法——和可得性偏差——即认为疥螨病在其农场经常发生的农民——通过计划行为理论的决定因素来解释。尽管这种从众偏差会影响农民的采用意愿,但可得性偏差的存在程度较低可能解释了为什么可持续疥螨病控制方法的采用意愿有限。其次,坚持默认治疗(默认偏差)会影响农民认为自己有能力在农场上实施控制方法的信念(感知行为控制),而认为实施控制方法被视为农场的成本而非益处(损失厌恶偏差)会对态度和感知行为控制产生负面影响。我们进一步讨论了可以激发农民采用意愿的重要影响因素。