College of Science, Xijing University, Xi'an, People's Republic of China.
Department of Communication Sciences and Disorders, Bowling Green State University, Bowling Green, Ohio.
J Voice. 2020 Nov;34(6):813-822. doi: 10.1016/j.jvoice.2019.06.005. Epub 2019 Jul 13.
Acoustic differences in the phonated sounds made by men and women are related to laryngeal and vocal tract structural differences. This model-based study explored how typical vocal fold differences between males and females affect intraglottal pressure distributions under conditions of different glottal angles and transglottal pressures, and thus how they may affect phonation. The computational code ANSYS Fluent 6.3 was used to obtain the pressure distributions and other aerodynamic parameters for laminar, incompressible flow. Typical values of the vocal fold length, the vertical glottal duct length, and the lateral vocal fold tissue depth were selected both for males and females under conditions of nine typical convergent/divergent glottal angles and three transglottal pressures. There was no coupling of the upstream or downstream vocal tracts, and also no vocal fold contact in these two-dimensional static glottal geometries. Results suggest that males tend to have greater intraglottal pressures for the convergent glottal shape that occurs during glottal opening, and the male glottis offers less flow resistance than the female glottis. These results suggest that the male vocal folds may vibrate more easily (ie, with lower transglottal pressure) but the tissue differences may nullify such an hypothesis. Also, the peak velocities in the glottis were dependent on the transglottal pressure driving the flow and the minimal glottal diameter, which were the same for both the male and female larynxes, rather than on the inferior-superior length of the glottis or the anterior-posterior glottal length. In addition, the tangential forces for larger glottal convergent angles was significantly greater in the female larynx. The entrance loss coefficients, however, were similar between the male and female larynxes, except for the uniform glottis for which the values were larger for the male larynx. The results suggest that the structural differences between male and female vocal folds should be well specified when building computational and physical models of the larynx.
男女发声时的声学差异与喉和声道结构的差异有关。本基于模型的研究探索了男性和女性典型的声带差异如何影响不同声门角和跨声门压下的声门腔内压力分布,以及它们如何影响发声。使用计算代码 ANSYS Fluent 6.3 获得层流、不可压缩流的压力分布和其他空气动力学参数。在九种典型的收敛/发散声门角和三种跨声门压条件下,为男性和女性选择了声带长度、垂直声门管长度和侧向声带组织深度的典型值。这些二维静态声门几何形状没有上游或下游声道的耦合,也没有声带接触。结果表明,在声门打开期间发生的收敛声门形状下,男性的声门腔内压力较大,男性声门的流动阻力小于女性声门。这些结果表明,男性声带可能更容易振动(即,跨声门压较低),但组织差异可能使这种假设无效。此外,声门中的峰值速度取决于驱动流动的跨声门压和最小声门直径,这对于男性和女性的喉都是相同的,而不是声门的上下长度或前后声门长度。此外,对于较大的声门收敛角,女性声门的切向力明显更大。然而,入口损失系数在男性和女性声门之间相似,除了均匀声门,其值对于男性声门较大。结果表明,在构建喉的计算和物理模型时,应充分说明男性和女性声带之间的结构差异。