Jain Swapnil, Varudkar H G, Julka Arti, Singapurwala Mustafa, Khosla Sourav, Shah Bhavya
Senior Resident,R.D. Gardi Medical College, Ujjain, Madhya Pradesh *Corresponding Author.
Prof. and HOD,R.D. Gardi Medical College, Ujjain, Madhya Pradesh.
J Assoc Physicians India. 2018 Dec;66(12):14-18.
To study the socio economical and clinico radiological profile of 474 diagnosed MDR TB cases who came for the initiation of MDR TB regimen in DRTB center of R.D.Gardi Medical college, Ujjain.
This is a retrospective and prospective observational study for a total period of three years from October 2013 to September 2016. The patients were evaluated clinically, radiologically and were investigated thoroughly according to PMDT guidelines and then were started on MDR TB treatment. The study was conducted at drug resistance tuberculosis center (DR-TB) managed by department of Pulmonary Medicine.
474 cases were included in the study and we found that patients were in the age range of 10-84 years, maximum patients were in age group of 30 to 39 years, and mean age was 38 yrs. Male to female ratio was 2.73 to 1, most of the patients in the study were from rural area i.e. 61.6%. Illiteracy was found in 339 (71.5%) cases and out of these 339, 165 patients (48.6%) were defaulter, 101(29.8%) are cases of relapse, 39(11.5%) were failure, 34(10.02%) of new cases. Maximum numbers of patient were in lower class accounting 63.7% and upper lower class 31.6%, lower middle class only 4.5%. Study also showed mean BMI was 14.9 kg/m2 (range 5.7-25.4 kg/m2), 88.6% of patients were undernourished with BMI less then 18.5kg/m2 .The most common symptoms was cough seen in 96%, followed by fever 67.5%, Dyspnea 52.7%, Anorexia 26.2%, chest pain in 19.8% and least common was haemoptysis seen in 7.6% of patient. Common co-morbidities with MDR-TB found was anemia in 176 out of 474 (i.e.37.1%), 123(25.9%) COPD. Radiological severity showed 219(46.2%) moderate lesion, 139 (29.3%) mild, 107(22.6%) extensive lesion and 9(1.9%) normal, 312(65.8%) of patient are non-cavitory and 162 (34.2%) are cavitory in which 99 (20.9%) were unilateral and 63(13.3%) are bilateral cavitory lesion. Defaulter are most common accounting of 218(46.0%), relapse139 (29.3%) and failure 68 (14.3%), new 48 (10.2%), most of them had taken more than one episode of ATT (72.8%). Most common source of ATT taken by patient is RNTCP it accounts 424 (89.5%) and 46 (9.7%) from private. 181 out of 474 (38.2%) cases delayed the treatment for 1-7 days, 82 out of 474 (17.3%) cases delayed treatment for 8-10 days, 96 out of 474 (20.3%) cases delayed treatment for 11-19 days and 115 out of 474 delayed the treatment for more than 19 days. 95 out of 474 cases i.e. 20.1% cases come from more than 150 km away from their residing area for the initiation of treatment.
The epidemiological picture of TB showed that males were predominant in our study however female were more affected in younger age group compared to male. More than 51% of the cases were in productive age group which affects the socioeconomic condition of family and society. More than 2/3 of patients were from lower socioeconomic group with low BMI. Therefore improving nutrition and immunity can play an important role. 2.3% of the cases were HIV reactive and were on ART. Co-morbidities like COPD and Diabetes were seen in our study which were statistically significant and had impact on the treatment outcome of results. Significant delay in initiation of MDR-TB regimen from date of DST was seen in 24.3% cases which is matter of concern. Most of the patients had taken ATT from RNTCP in which Defaulter and relapse was major contributor of MDR-TB suspect in our study and patient taking ATT privately were less. Large number of cases which resides more than 150 kilometers from DRTB center initiated the drug after a gap of more than 19 days from the date of DST.
研究474例确诊的耐多药结核病患者的社会经济状况以及临床放射学特征,这些患者前往乌贾因R.D.加尔迪医学院耐多药结核病中心开始接受耐多药结核病治疗方案。
这是一项回顾性和前瞻性观察性研究,为期三年,从2013年10月至2016年9月。对患者进行临床、放射学评估,并根据国家结核病防治规划(PMDT)指南进行全面检查,然后开始耐多药结核病治疗。该研究在由肺病科管理的耐药结核病中心(DR-TB)进行。
474例患者纳入研究,发现患者年龄在10 - 84岁之间,最大患者群体在30至39岁年龄组,平均年龄为38岁。男女比例为2.73比1,研究中的大多数患者来自农村地区,即61.6%。339例(71.5%)患者为文盲,其中165例(48.6%)患者为违约者,101例(29.8%)为复发病例,39例(11.5%)治疗失败,34例(10.02%)为新病例。最大数量的患者处于下层社会经济阶层,占63.7%,中下层社会经济阶层占31.6%,中产阶级仅占4.5%。研究还显示平均体重指数(BMI)为14.9kg/m²(范围为5.7 - 25.4kg/m²),88.6%的患者营养不良,BMI低于18.5kg/m²。最常见的症状是咳嗽,占96%,其次是发热67.5%,呼吸困难52.7%,厌食26.2%,胸痛19.8%,最不常见的是咯血,见于7.6%的患者。耐多药结核病常见的合并症为贫血,474例中有176例(即37.1%),慢性阻塞性肺疾病(COPD)123例(25.9%)。放射学严重程度显示219例(46.2%)为中度病变,139例(29.3%)为轻度病变,107例(22.6%)为广泛病变,9例(1.9%)正常,312例(65.8%)患者无空洞,162例(34.2%)有空洞,其中99例(20.9%)为单侧空洞,63例(13.3%)为双侧空洞病变。违约者最为常见,占218例(46.0%),复发139例(29.3%),失败68例(14.3%),新病例48例(10.2%),大多数患者接受过不止一轮的抗结核治疗(ATT)(72.8%)。患者接受抗结核治疗最常见的来源是国家结核病防治规划,占424例(89.5%),来自私立机构的占46例(9.7%)。474例中有181例(38.2%)患者延迟治疗1 - 7天,474例中有82例(17.3%)患者延迟治疗8 - 10天,474例中有96例(20.3%)患者延迟治疗11 - 19天,474例中有115例延迟治疗超过19天。474例中有95例(即20.1%)患者从居住地区超过150公里外前来开始治疗。
结核病的流行病学情况表明,在我们的研究中男性占主导,但在年轻年龄组中女性比男性受影响更大。超过51%的病例处于生产年龄组,这影响了家庭和社会的社会经济状况。超过三分之二的患者来自社会经济地位较低的群体,BMI较低。因此,改善营养和免疫力可以发挥重要作用。2.3%的病例HIV检测呈阳性并正在接受抗逆转录病毒治疗(ART)。在我们的研究中发现了如COPD和糖尿病等合并症,这些合并症具有统计学意义,并对治疗结果产生影响。24.3%的病例从药敏试验(DST)日期起开始耐多药结核病治疗方案有显著延迟,这是一个值得关注的问题。大多数患者接受的抗结核治疗来自国家结核病防治规划,其中违约者和复发者是我们研究中耐多药结核病疑似病例的主要贡献者,而私下接受抗结核治疗的患者较少。大量居住在距离耐多药结核病中心超过150公里的病例从药敏试验日期起超过19天后才开始用药。