Thiébot M H, Soubrié P, Sanger D
INSERM U 302, Département de Pharmacologie, Faculté de Médecine Pitié-Salpêtrière, Paris, France.
Psychopharmacology (Berl). 1988;94(4):452-63. doi: 10.1007/BF00212837.
The behavioral effects of the benzodiazepine (BZP)-receptor partial inverse agonists, beta-CCE and FG 7142, are reviewed and the claim that these compounds possess "anxiogenic" properties is examined. Results obtained from human studies and global observations in animals, as well as those from experiments on aggression in animals or from studies of pentylenetetrazole discrimination cannot be considered conclusive. Contradictory findings have been obtained in studies using animal testing procedures derived from BZP-sensitive models of anxiety and in newer experimental situations and these are discussed from various theoretical perspectives: (1) the ability of the models to measure increased anxiety; (2) the possible ability of the drugs to reveal latent anxiety which generalizes from a punished to an otherwise non-fearful component of a testing procedure ("spreading anxiety"); (3) anxiety produced by a pro- or pre-convulsant state. Finally, several hypotheses are considered to account for the behavioral effects of beta-CCE and FG 7142 without assuming anxiogenic properties. These include the possible existence of different forms of anxiety, rate dependency, and drug-induced motivational changes. It is concluded that available data are insufficient to strongly support the notion that FG 7142 and beta-CCE are the anxiogenic drugs "par excellence" they are often claimed to be.
本文综述了苯二氮䓬(BZP)受体部分反向激动剂β-CCE和FG 7142的行为效应,并对这些化合物具有“致焦虑”特性的说法进行了研究。来自人体研究、动物整体观察、动物攻击实验或戊四氮辨别研究的结果都不能被视为确凿无疑。在使用源自对BZP敏感的焦虑模型的动物测试程序以及新的实验情境的研究中,得到了相互矛盾的结果,并从各种理论角度进行了讨论:(1)模型测量焦虑增加的能力;(2)药物揭示潜在焦虑的可能能力,这种潜在焦虑从测试程序中受惩罚的部分扩散到原本无恐惧的部分(“扩散性焦虑”);(3)惊厥前或惊厥状态产生的焦虑。最后,在不假定具有致焦虑特性的情况下,考虑了几个假说来解释β-CCE和FG 7142的行为效应。这些假说包括不同形式焦虑的可能存在、速率依赖性以及药物诱导的动机变化。结论是,现有数据不足以有力支持FG 7142和β-CCE是它们常被宣称的那种“典型致焦虑药物”这一观点。