Center for Analytics and Informatics, Atrius Health, Newton, Massachusetts, USA.
Department of Biomedical Informatics and Medical Education, University of Washington, Seattle, Washington, USA.
J Am Med Inform Assoc. 2019 Oct 1;26(10):920-927. doi: 10.1093/jamia/ocz025.
The purpose of this study was to determine if medication cost transparency alerts provided at time of prescribing led ambulatory prescribers to reduce their use of low-value medications.
Provider-level alerts were deployed to ambulatory practices of a single health system from February 2018 through April 2018. Practice sites included 58 primary care and 152 specialty care clinics totaling 1896 attending physicians, residents, and advanced practice nurses throughout western Washington. Prescribers in the randomly assigned intervention arm received a computerized alert whenever they ordered a medication among 4 high-cost medication classes. For each class, a lower cost, equally effective, and safe alternative was available. The primary outcome was the change in prescribing volume for each of the 4 selected medication classes during the 12-week intervention period relative to a prior 24-week baseline.
A total of 15 456 prescriptions for high-cost medications were written during the baseline period including 7223 in the intervention arm and 8233 in the control arm. During the intervention period, a decrease in daily prescribing volume was noted for all high-cost medications including 33% for clobetasol propionate (p < .0001), 59% for doxycycline hyclate (p < .0001), 43% for fluoxetine tablets (p < .0001), and a non-significant 3% decrease for high-cost triptans (p = .65). Prescribing volume for the high-cost medications overall decreased by 32% (p < .0001).
Medication cost transparency alerts in an ambulatory setting lead to more cost-conscious prescribing. Future work is needed to predict which alerts will be most effective.
本研究旨在确定在开处方时提供药物费用透明度警报是否会导致门诊开处方者减少低价值药物的使用。
2018 年 2 月至 2018 年 4 月期间,向单一健康系统的门诊实践部署了提供者层面的警报。实践地点包括 58 个初级保健诊所和 152 个专科保健诊所,共有 1896 名主治医生、住院医生和西华盛顿地区的高级执业护士。在随机分配的干预组中,每当他们开处方时,都会收到一种计算机化的警报,这些药物属于 4 种高成本药物类别。对于每个类别,都有一个成本较低、同样有效且安全的替代品。主要结果是在 12 周干预期间,与之前的 24 周基线相比,这 4 种选定药物类别中每种药物的处方量变化。
在基线期间共开出 15456 份高成本药物处方,其中干预组 7223 份,对照组 8233 份。在干预期间,所有高成本药物的每日处方量均有所下降,包括丙酸氯倍他索(p<0.0001)下降 33%、盐酸多西环素(p<0.0001)下降 59%、氟西汀片(p<0.0001)下降 43%,而高成本曲坦类药物(p=0.65)则无显著下降 3%。高成本药物的处方量总体下降 32%(p<0.0001)。
在门诊环境中提供药物费用透明度警报会导致更具成本意识的处方。需要进一步研究来预测哪些警报最有效。