David Tvildiani Medical University, Tbilisi, Georgia.
Georgian Med News. 2019 May(290):89-96.
The aim of the research was standard and alternative measurement of anthropometric indices in Georgian healthy elderly population for determining the reliability/validity of the widely used and recognized assessment tools. Our research is the first study of the anthropometry as the part of of nutritional status assessment in Georgian elderly. For anthropometric assessment we first time used 1. Standard measurements (weight, height, WC, HC, MAC /MUAC, TSF, BMI, WHR, AMA using standard methods and tools for measurable values and standard formulas for calculating values), and 2. Alternative measurements (demispan, demispan equivalent height and BMI (DEH, DE BMI), Mindex for women, Demiquet for men. using Bassey's equations). Our study group formed for the nutritional status assessment in Georgian healthy elderly (Study group ≥ 60 y (n=75): men (n=14); women (n=61). Subgroup <75 y (n=64): men (n=9); women (n=55); Subgroup 75+ y (n=11); men (n=5); women (n=6)). Based on BMI range, the data from 78.7% of participants' were above the norm, 21.3% - normal and 0 - below the norm. The findings of our study have shown that BMI is not height-dependent variable, moreover, BMI as mindex and demiquet is a mass/weight-dependent anthropometric characteristic. BMI, demiquet and mindex had nearly same correlation with other anthropometric parameters (especially for women). High correlation between direct measured/calculated BMI and DE BMI were confirmed by Pearson coefficient 0.979 (p<0.01). The Cohen's Unweighted Kappa index was 0.8518 (0.81 - 1.00 almost perfect or perfect agreement). According to the Paired Samples Test results, there were no difference between BMI and DE BMI. Statistically significant difference between the BMI and DE BMI was determined only for men (0.003 - difference is significant at p<0.05). However, there were only 14 men in our research group and the use of this method recommended in a larger group. Graphical Bland and Altman agreement analysis demonstrated the absence of the trends in differences between BMI and DE BMI. The findings of our research confirm that Demi-span is a reliable measure of stature in Georgian healthy elderly. Demiquet and Mindex are useful indices for our population and suitable for use in clinical practice and in the study of the Georgian elderly when the use of standard weight to height indices may be questionable. Considering to results of statistical analysis, strength of correlation and agreement between direct measured BMI and alternative BMI confirms that the Bassey's equation is valid for Georgian healthy elderly, Demispan equivalent height and BMI is reliable and, accordingly, useful in case of lack of standard calculations or to avoid errors of direct measurements. However, further studies with higher subject numbers are needed to confirm our findings. Additional studies covering other communities in Georgia with different socioeconomic and ethnic composition, also, with different diseases would be necessary to obtain a better anthropometric characterization of the Georgian elderly.
本研究的目的是对格鲁吉亚健康老年人进行人体测量学的标准和替代测量,以确定广泛使用和认可的评估工具的可靠性/有效性。我们的研究是格鲁吉亚老年人营养状况评估中人体测量学的首次研究。为了进行人体测量评估,我们首次使用了 1. 标准测量(体重、身高、WC、HC、MAC/MUAC、TSF、BMI、WHR、AMA,使用可测量值的标准方法和工具以及计算值的标准公式)和 2. 替代测量(半身跨度、半身跨度等效身高和 BMI(DEH、DE BMI)、女性的 Mindex、男性的 Demiquet,使用 Bassey 的方程)。我们的研究组由格鲁吉亚健康老年人的营养状况评估组成(研究组≥60 岁(n=75):男性(n=14);女性(n=61)。<75 岁亚组(n=64):男性(n=9);女性(n=55);75+岁亚组(n=11):男性(n=5);女性(n=6))。基于 BMI 范围,78.7%参与者的数据高于正常值,21.3%为正常值,0%为低于正常值。我们的研究结果表明,BMI 不是身高依赖的变量,此外,BMI 作为 mindex 和 Demiquet 是一个与体重/重量相关的人体测量特征。BMI、Demiquet 和 Mindex 与其他人体测量参数(尤其是女性)几乎具有相同的相关性。Pearson 系数为 0.979(p<0.01)证实了直接测量/计算的 BMI 与 DE BMI 之间的高度相关性。Cohen 未加权 Kappa 指数为 0.8518(0.81-1.00 几乎完美或完全一致)。根据配对样本检验结果,BMI 和 DE BMI 之间没有差异。仅在男性中确定了 BMI 和 DE BMI 之间的统计学显著差异(0.003-差异在 p<0.05 时显著)。然而,我们的研究组中只有 14 名男性,因此建议在更大的人群中使用这种方法。图形 Bland 和 Altman 一致性分析表明 BMI 和 DE BMI 之间没有差异趋势。我们的研究结果证实,在格鲁吉亚健康老年人中,半身跨度是一种可靠的身高测量方法。Demiquet 和 Mindex 是我们人群中有用的指标,适用于临床实践和格鲁吉亚老年人的研究,因为标准体重与身高指数的使用可能值得怀疑。考虑到统计分析的结果、直接测量的 BMI 与替代 BMI 之间的相关性和一致性的强度,Bassey 方程对格鲁吉亚健康老年人是有效的,等效身高和 BMI 是可靠的,因此在缺乏标准计算或避免直接测量误差的情况下是有用的。然而,需要更多的具有更高受试者数量的研究来证实我们的发现。需要进行更多的研究,涵盖格鲁吉亚具有不同社会经济和种族构成以及不同疾病的其他社区,以更好地对格鲁吉亚老年人进行人体测量学特征描述。