Department of Neurology, SUNY Upstate Medical University, United States.
Center for Research and Evaluation, SUNY Upstate Medical University, United States.
J Clin Neurosci. 2019 Nov;69:237-240. doi: 10.1016/j.jocn.2019.07.043. Epub 2019 Jul 18.
The current standard-of-care protocol for OnabotulinumtoxinA (BoNTA) injections consists of fixed-site injections every 12 weeks. This pattern is based on clinical practice and extrapolated from BoNTA injections for other, non-migraine-related indications. It is unclear if this protocol is optimal for chronic migraine. In clinical practice, migraine patients frequently describe a period of increased headache frequency and intensity in the few weeks preceding their next injections. In order to evaluate the duration of the clinical effect of BoNTA injections in chronic migraine, we studied the variation in headache frequency on a weekly basis during the 12-week period following treatment in a cohort of migraine patients.
38 consecutive subjects were enrolled from an outpatient headache clinic, and asked to keep daily headache journals. 24 completed headache journals were analyzed. Headache frequency, duration and severity, as well as intake of symptomatic headache medications were recorded and compared among the different weeks.
The time-response plot following BoNTA injection was roughly U-shaped, with 3 distinct phases: an induction phase, a maximum efficacy phase, and a wear-off phase. The time-response plot revealed that the wear-off commenced around the eighth week post injection. The mean difference in the number of headache days per week between the first and the eighth week was 1.8 (95% CI [0.670-2.830], p = 0.003).
The effect of BoNTA injections on chronic migraines was not uniform throughout a 12-week period. A window of vulnerability to migraine attacks exist in the beginning and end of each cycle.
目前,肉毒毒素 A(BoNTA)注射的标准治疗方案包括每 12 周进行固定部位注射。这种模式基于临床实践,并从 BoNTA 治疗其他非偏头痛相关适应症中推断而来。目前尚不清楚这种方案是否最适合慢性偏头痛。在临床实践中,偏头痛患者经常在下次注射前的几周内描述头痛频率和强度增加的时期。为了评估 BoNTA 注射在慢性偏头痛中的临床效果持续时间,我们研究了在偏头痛患者的治疗后 12 周内每周头痛频率的变化。
从一个门诊头痛诊所招募了 38 名连续患者,并要求他们每天记录头痛日记。分析了 24 份完整的头痛日记。记录并比较了不同周期间的头痛频率、持续时间和严重程度,以及对症头痛药物的摄入量。
BoNTA 注射后的时间反应图大致呈 U 形,有 3 个不同阶段:诱导期、最大疗效期和失效期。时间反应图显示,失效期大约在注射后第 8 周开始。第一周和第八周每周头痛天数的平均差异为 1.8(95%CI [0.670-2.830],p=0.003)。
BoNTA 注射对慢性偏头痛的效果在 12 周内并不均匀。在每个周期的开始和结束时都存在偏头痛发作的脆弱窗口。