Suppressive effects of N-bisphosphonate in osteoblastic cells mitigated by non-N-bisphosphonate but not by sodium-dependent phosphate cotransporter inhibitor.

There are two types of bisphosphonates (BPs), nitrogen-containing (N-BPs) and those free from nitrogen (non-N-BPs). Although N-BPs show greater inhibition of bone resorption than non-N-BPs, their effects are likely accompanied with inflammation, which non-N-BPs mitigate. We examined the competitive effects of zoledronate (ZOL), an N-BP, and etidronate (ETI), a non-N-BP, in osteoblasts. ZOL, but not ETI, markedly reduced alkaline phosphatase activity and cell viability in osteoblastic MC3T3-E1 and Saos2 cells, while that inhibition was relieved by simultaneous administration of ETI, possibly because of competition with ZOL for cellular uptake. However, phosphonoformate, an inhibitor of the phosphonate transporters SLC20A and SLC34A, did not mitigate the reducing effects of ZOL, suggesting that those transporters are not involved in BP uptake in osteoblastic cells. Additionally, ZOL reduced fibroblastic NIH3T3 and C3H10T1/2 cell viability, which was relieved by administration of both ETI and phosphonoformate. Transporter gene expression levels were significantly lower in osteoblasts as compared with fibroblasts, which may account for the distinct effects of phosphonoformate with different cell types. Together, our results suggest existence of a common uptake route of N-BPs and non-N-BPs into osteoblastic cells that is unrelated to the SLC20A and SLC34A families. SIGNIFICANCE OF THE STUDY: N-BP ZOL was shown to suppress differentiation and viability of osteoblasts. ZOL-induced cell viability suppression was also observed in fibroblasts, which was markedly relieved by addition of the non-N-BP ETI. Additionally, mitigation of the effects of ZOL was achieved with phosphonoformate, a sodium-phosphate cotransporter inhibitor, in fibroblastic cells but not osteoblasts. Expression levels of SLC20A and SLC34A family genes were significantly lower in osteoblasts as compared with fibroblasts. These observations suggest that incorporation of N-BPs and non-N-BPs in osteoblasts is mediated via common transporters that appear to be distinct from SLC20A and 34A, which operate in fibroblasts.