Health Systems Research Department, KEMRI-Wellcome Trust Research Programme, Nairobi, Kenya.
Department for Reproductive Health and Research, World Health Organization, Avenue Appia 20, Geneva 1211, Switzerland.
Health Policy Plan. 2019 May 1;34(4):249-256. doi: 10.1093/heapol/czz019.
Women comprise a significant proportion of the health workforce globally but remain under-represented in the higher professional categories. Concern about the under-representation of women in health leadership positions has resulted in increased research on the topic, although this research has focused primarily on high-income countries. An improved understanding of the career trajectories and experiences of healthcare leaders in low- and middle-income countries (LMICs), and the role of gender, is therefore needed. This qualitative case study was undertaken in two counties in coastal Kenya. Drawing on the life-history approach, 12 male and 13 female healthcare leaders were interviewed between August 2015 and July 2016 on their career progression and related experiences. Although gender was not spontaneously identified as a significant influence, closer exploration of responses revealed that gendered factors played an important role. Most fundamentally, women's role as child bearers and gendered societal expectations including child nurturing and other domestic responsibilities can influence their ability to take up leadership opportunities, and their selection and appointment as leaders. Women's selection and appointment as leaders may also be influenced by positive discrimination policies (in favour of women), and by perceptions of women and men as having different leadership styles (against women, who some described as more emotive and reactive). These gendered influences intersect in relatively invisible ways with other factors more readily identified by respondents to influence their progression and experience. These factors included: professional cadre, with doctors more likely to be selected into leadership roles; and personal and professional support systems ranging from family support and role models, through to professional mentorship and continuing education. We discuss the implications of these findings for policy, practice and research, including highlighting the need for more in-depth intersectionality analyses of leadership experience in LMICs.
女性在全球卫生劳动力中占很大比例,但在高职业类别中代表性仍然不足。对女性在卫生领导职位中代表性不足的关注导致了对该主题的研究增加,尽管这些研究主要集中在高收入国家。因此,需要更好地了解中低收入国家(LMICs)医疗保健领导者的职业轨迹和经验,以及性别的作用。这项定性案例研究在肯尼亚沿海的两个县进行。研究人员采用生命史方法,于 2015 年 8 月至 2016 年 7 月期间对 12 名男性和 13 名女性医疗保健领导者进行了访谈,内容涉及他们的职业发展和相关经历。尽管性别没有被自发认为是一个重要的影响因素,但对回应的更深入探讨表明,性别因素发挥了重要作用。最根本的是,女性作为生育者的角色以及包括儿童养育和其他家务责任在内的性别化社会期望会影响她们担任领导职务的能力,以及她们作为领导者的选拔和任命。女性作为领导者的选拔和任命也可能受到有利于女性的积极歧视政策的影响,以及人们对男女不同领导风格的看法(反对女性,一些人认为女性更情绪化和反应性)的影响。这些性别影响以相对不可见的方式与其他因素相互交织,这些因素更容易被受访者识别,从而影响他们的发展和经验。这些因素包括:专业干部,医生更有可能被选入领导角色;以及个人和专业支持系统,从家庭支持和榜样,到专业指导和继续教育。我们讨论了这些发现对政策、实践和研究的影响,包括强调需要对 LMICs 的领导经验进行更深入的交叉性分析。