Kwong Jacky Z, Gray Jennifer M, Rein Lisa, Liu Ying, Melzer-Lange Marlene D
1Department of Pediatrics - Section of Emergency Medicine, Medical College of Wisconsin, 8701 W Watertown Plank Rd, Milwaukee, WI 53226 USA.
2Department of Biostatistics, Medical College of Wisconsin, 8701 W Watertown Plank Rd, Milwaukee, WI 53226 USA.
Inj Epidemiol. 2019 May 29;6(Suppl 1):27. doi: 10.1186/s40621-019-0201-3. eCollection 2019.
Most physicians support counseling patients about firearm injury prevention (FIP), but infrequently do so due to lack of training and low confidence. Interventions to increase counseling frequency should focus on improving physician self-efficacy. Firearm injuries affect many clinical specialties; therefore, trainees would benefit from early FIP education. This study aims to determine if a 20-min educational intervention improves self-efficacy in FIP counseling in third-year medical students. Knowledge and beliefs were also assessed as secondary indicators of self-efficacy.
This was a prospective study performed at a medical school associated with a tertiary care children's hospital during the 2016-17 academic year. Groups of 12-15 different third-year medical students were selected to receive either a 20-min intervention or control lecture during their monthly pediatric lectures. The intervention consisted of two clinical vignettes, a brief discussion about the importance of FIP, and suggestions for clinical integration. The control session was a case-based lecture about pediatric emergencies. Participants completed baseline electronic assessments. Intervention students also completed post-intervention assessments immediately following each session. All participants completed final assessments at 6 months. Data were analyzed using Wilcoxon signed-rank tests and Wilcoxon rank-sum.
We surveyed a total of 130 students. Sixty-five students completed the entire series of assessments - 22 from the control and 43 from the intervention group. There were no significant differences between the control and intervention groups at baseline. Immediately after, intervention, participants reported feeling more self-efficacious, had improved knowledge of FIP risk factors, and had beliefs more consistent with providing FIP anticipatory guidance ( < 0.001 for all three measures). After 6 months, participants sustained improvement in one of two self-efficacy questions ("I feel ready to counsel patients about firearm injury prevention") and retained knowledge of risk factors ( < 0.05 for both). However, their beliefs did not significantly favor FIP counseling, and they were not more likely to engage in a conversation about firearm safety.
A 20-min educational intervention acutely improved self-efficacy in FIP counseling in third-year medical students, but improvements weakened after six months. Without further training, the beneficial effects of a one-time intervention will likely wane with time.
大多数医生支持就枪支伤害预防(FIP)对患者进行咨询,但由于缺乏培训和信心不足,很少这样做。提高咨询频率的干预措施应侧重于提高医生的自我效能感。枪支伤害影响许多临床专科;因此,实习生将从早期的FIP教育中受益。本研究旨在确定一项20分钟的教育干预是否能提高三年级医学生在FIP咨询方面的自我效能感。知识和信念也作为自我效能感的次要指标进行评估。
这是一项前瞻性研究,于2016 - 17学年在一所与三级儿童医院相关的医学院进行。在每月的儿科讲座期间,选取12 - 15名不同的三年级医学生组成的小组,分别接受20分钟的干预或对照讲座。干预包括两个临床案例、关于FIP重要性的简短讨论以及临床整合建议。对照课程是一个关于儿科急诊的案例讲座。参与者完成基线电子评估。干预组学生在每次课程结束后立即完成干预后评估。所有参与者在6个月时完成最终评估。数据采用Wilcoxon符号秩检验和Wilcoxon秩和检验进行分析。
我们共调查了130名学生。65名学生完成了整个系列评估——22名来自对照组,43名来自干预组。对照组和干预组在基线时无显著差异。干预后,参与者报告感觉自我效能感更强,对FIP危险因素的了解有所改善,并且信念更符合提供FIP预期指导(所有三项指标均P < 0.001)。6个月后,参与者在两个自我效能感问题之一( “我觉得自己准备好就枪支伤害预防向患者咨询” )上持续改善,并且保留了对危险因素的了解(两者均P < 0.05)。然而,他们的信念并不显著倾向于FIP咨询,并且他们进行关于枪支安全对话的可能性也没有增加。
一项20分钟的教育干预能迅速提高三年级医学生在FIP咨询方面的自我效能感,但6个月后改善减弱。如果没有进一步培训,一次性干预的有益效果可能会随着时间减弱。