The University of Texas MD Anderson Cancer Center, Houston, TX.
Baylor College of Medicine, Houston, TX.
J Natl Cancer Inst. 2020 Feb 1;112(2):211-213. doi: 10.1093/jnci/djz154.
Landmark investigation two decades ago demonstrated sex-based disparities among participants in cancer cooperative group trials. Although federal efforts have aimed to improve representation of female patients in government-sponsored research, less is known about sex disparities in the broader landscape of modern oncologic randomized controlled trials. Using ClinicalTrials.gov, we identified randomized controlled trials related to colorectal or lung cancer (the two most common non-sex-specific disease sites). Among the 147 included trials, the proportion of female patients enrolled on trial was on average 6.8% (95% confidence interval = -8.8% to -4.9%) less than the proportion of female patients in the population by disease site (P < .001). Whereas no statistically significant underrepresentation of women was noted within the 26 cooperative group trials, sex disparities were markedly heightened for the 121 noncooperative-group-sponsored trials. Furthermore, underrepresentation of women did not improve with time. Future efforts should therefore focus on addressing these pervasive sex-based enrollment disparities beyond cooperative group trials alone.
二十年前的一项里程碑式研究表明,癌症合作组试验参与者存在性别差异。尽管联邦政府努力旨在提高女性患者在政府资助研究中的代表性,但对于更广泛的现代肿瘤学随机对照试验中性别差异的了解较少。我们使用 ClinicalTrials.gov 确定了与结直肠癌或肺癌相关的随机对照试验(这是两个最常见的非特定性别疾病部位)。在纳入的 147 项试验中,试验中招募的女性患者比例平均比按疾病部位划分的女性患者比例低 6.8%(95%置信区间=-8.8%至-4.9%)(P<.001)。虽然在 26 项合作组试验中没有发现女性明显代表性不足的情况,但对于 121 项非合作组赞助的试验,性别差异明显加剧。此外,女性代表性不足的情况并没有随着时间的推移而改善。因此,未来的努力应重点解决这些普遍存在的基于性别的入组差异,而不仅仅是合作组试验。