Li Niying, Wang Zhan, Dear Keith
Social and Administrative Sciences in Pharmacy Division, School of Pharmacy, University of Wisconsin-Madison, USA, 53705.
Department of Agricultural Economics, College of Agriculture, Purdue University, 47907, USA.
J Forensic Leg Med. 2019 Oct;67:1-6. doi: 10.1016/j.jflm.2019.07.006. Epub 2019 Jul 23.
This study aims to extend the current understanding of violence against health professionals and facilities in China, with data from an authoritative, national-representative, but under-researched data source - litigation records, and discuss implications for developing violence prevention strategies.
We collected all legal cases relevant to violence against health professionals and facilities from criminal ligation records released by the Supreme Court of China from 2010 to 2016.
(i) Characteristics of perpetrators: gender, age, education, occupation, history of mental illness and alcohol; (ii) characteristics of victims: medical specialization, location, type of violence; (iii) outcome of treatment.
140 cases were collected for analysis. Beating, pushing, verbal abuse, threatening, burning mock paper money, placing a corpse in the hospital, hanging banners, blocking hospital gates and doors, and smashing hospital property were the most frequently reported types of violence. Specifically following patient deaths, the interval between a patient's death and violence by the patient's families and friends was short, with 51% happening on the same day.
Our study provides a comprehensive overview of violence against health professionals and facilities in China, which can be used to inform the development of prevention strategies.
本研究旨在通过来自一个权威的、具有全国代表性但研究不足的数据源——诉讼记录的数据,拓展对中国针对医护人员及医疗机构暴力行为的当前认识,并探讨对制定暴力预防策略的启示。
我们从中国最高法院2010年至2016年发布的刑事诉讼记录中收集了所有与针对医护人员及医疗机构暴力行为相关的法律案件。
(i)施暴者特征:性别、年龄、教育程度、职业、精神病史和饮酒情况;(ii)受害者特征:医学专业、地点、暴力类型;(iii)治疗结果。
共收集140例案件进行分析。殴打、推搡、言语辱骂、威胁、烧纸、在医院停放尸体、拉横幅、封堵医院大门和门以及砸毁医院财物是最常报告的暴力类型。具体而言,在患者死亡后,患者家属和朋友实施暴力与患者死亡之间的间隔时间较短,51%发生在同一天。
我们的研究全面概述了中国针对医护人员及医疗机构的暴力行为,可用于为预防策略的制定提供参考。