Department of Surgery, Asahi General Hospital.
Division of Vascular Surgery, Department of Surgery, The University of Tokyo.
Circ J. 2019 Aug 23;83(9):1868-1875. doi: 10.1253/circj.CJ-19-0386. Epub 2019 Jul 27.
Since endovascular aneurysm repair has become predominant, the issue of training young vascular surgeons in open abdominal aortic aneurysm (AAA) surgery has received significant attention. Through learning curve analysis, we aimed to determine the number of cases needed for young surgeons to achieve satisfactory open surgical skills.
A total of 562 consecutive patients who underwent open repair either by an attending surgeon (group A) or 6 young vascular surgeons (group Y) were included and assessed with regards to the preparation, clamp, and total operation times. Although some of the patients' characteristics were different, the surgical procedures were comparable between the 2 groups. There was a clear trend towards a decrease in each 10 successive cases in group Y. The operation times in group A were constant at 72±30 (preparation), 48±10 (clamp), and 231±59 min (total), which were achieved by young vascular surgeons in 10, 30, and 10 cases, respectively. In the cumulative sum analysis, 25-27 cases were necessary for young vascular surgeons to enhance their surgical skills. The complication rate in group Y was no higher than that in group A.
Young vascular surgeons can safely learn open AAA repair without increasing operation time or complications. Approximately 30 cases would be necessary to gain satisfactory surgical skills.
随着血管内动脉瘤修复术的普及,年轻血管外科医师在开放性腹主动脉瘤(AAA)手术方面的培训问题受到了广泛关注。通过学习曲线分析,我们旨在确定年轻外科医师达到满意的开放性手术技能所需的病例数。
共纳入 562 例连续接受开放性修复的患者,其中由主治外科医师(A 组)或 6 名年轻血管外科医师(Y 组)完成,并评估了准备、夹闭和总手术时间。尽管两组患者的一些特征不同,但手术过程是可比的。Y 组中每连续 10 例手术,各项时间都呈现出明显的下降趋势。A 组的手术时间分别为 72±30 分钟(准备)、48±10 分钟(夹闭)和 231±59 分钟(总时间),这是由年轻血管外科医师在 10、30 和 10 例手术中分别实现的。在累积和分析中,年轻血管外科医师需要进行 25-27 例手术才能提高手术技能。Y 组的并发症发生率并不高于 A 组。
年轻血管外科医师可以安全地学习开放性 AAA 修复术,而不会增加手术时间或并发症。大约需要 30 例手术才能获得满意的手术技能。