Center for Gender Research and Early Detection, University of Basel Psychiatric Hospital, Basel, Switzerland.
Department of Psychology, Division of Clinical Psychology and Epidemiology, University of Basel, Basel, Switzerland.
Schizophr Bull. 2020 Feb 26;46(2):252-260. doi: 10.1093/schbul/sbz059.
The prediction of outcomes in patients at Clinical High Risk for Psychosis (CHR-P) almost exclusively relies on static data obtained at a single snapshot in time (ie, baseline data). Although the CHR-P symptoms are intrinsically evolving over time, available prediction models cannot be dynamically updated to reflect these changes. Hence, the aim of this study was to develop and internally validate a dynamic risk prediction model (joint model) and to implement this model in a user-friendly online risk calculator. Furthermore, we aimed to explore the prognostic performance of extended dynamic risk prediction models and to compare static with dynamic prediction. One hundred ninety-six CHR-P patients were recruited as part of the "Basel Früherkennung von Psychosen" (FePsy) study. Psychopathology and transition to psychosis was assessed at regular intervals for up to 5 years using the Brief Psychiatric Rating Scale-Expanded (BPRS-E). Various specifications of joint models were compared with regard to their cross-validated prognostic performance. We developed and internally validated a joint model that predicts psychosis onset from BPRS-E disorganization and years of education at baseline and BPRS-E positive symptoms during the follow-up with good prognostic performance. The model was implemented as online risk calculator (http://www.fepsy.ch/DPRP/). The use of extended joint models slightly increased the prognostic accuracy compared to basic joint models, and dynamic models showed a higher prognostic accuracy than static models. Our results confirm that extended joint modeling could improve the prediction of psychosis in CHR-P patients. We implemented the first online risk calculator that can dynamically update psychosis risk prediction.
对处于精神病临床高危状态(CHR-P)的患者的结局预测几乎完全依赖于在单一时间点(即基线数据)获得的静态数据。尽管 CHR-P 症状本质上是随时间演变的,但现有的预测模型无法动态更新以反映这些变化。因此,本研究旨在开发和内部验证动态风险预测模型(联合模型),并将其实现为用户友好的在线风险计算器。此外,我们旨在探索扩展的动态风险预测模型的预后性能,并比较静态与动态预测。196 名 CHR-P 患者作为“巴塞尔精神病早期发现”(FePsy)研究的一部分被招募。使用扩展的Brief 精神病评定量表(BPRS-E)定期评估精神病学和向精神病的转变,最长可达 5 年。比较了联合模型的各种规格,以评估其交叉验证的预后性能。我们开发并内部验证了一种联合模型,该模型可以根据 BPRS-E 紊乱和基线时的受教育年限以及随访期间的 BPRS-E 阳性症状预测精神病发作,具有良好的预后性能。该模型已实现为在线风险计算器(http://www.fepsy.ch/DPRP/)。与基本联合模型相比,扩展联合模型的使用略微提高了预测准确性,动态模型的预测准确性高于静态模型。我们的研究结果证实,扩展的联合建模可以改善对 CHR-P 患者的精神病预测。我们实现了第一个可以动态更新精神病风险预测的在线风险计算器。