J Phys Act Health. 2019 Oct 1;16(10):843-850. doi: 10.1123/jpah.2018-0583. Epub 2019 Jul 26.
The reasons for the mixed evidence of the effectiveness of school-based physical activity programs can be many, including implementation challenges. Studying program implementation can potentially contribute to enhancing effectiveness, the design of future interventions, improved implementation, and the interpretation of outcomes.
For this process evaluation, individual interviews were conducted with 16 teachers who had implemented the program "Active All Year Round" in a fifth-grade school class (students aged 9-11 y) in 2017. Through systematic text condensation feasibility and barriers of program implementation, perceived program reach and the programs' influence on social cohesion were identified and discussed.
Teachers described the program as very feasible to implement and identified very few implementation barriers, the most prominent being time constrains. Perceived program reach was very high, and teachers reported that those students who are less confident when it comes to physical activity did not have differential participation than those feeling more confident about physical activity. Finally, the program was perceived to positively affect social cohesion in class.
Active All Year Round is a standardized, flexible, and easily implemented program in Danish schools. Future studies are needed to study implementation from a student's perspective and/or students' role in and experiences with competition-based health programs.
学校体育活动项目有效性的证据存在差异,原因可能有很多,包括实施方面的挑战。研究项目的实施情况可能有助于提高效果、设计未来的干预措施、改进实施情况以及解释结果。
在这项过程评估中,对 16 名教师进行了个体访谈,他们在 2017 年的五年级班级(9-11 岁的学生)中实施了“全年积极活动”项目。通过系统的文本压缩,确定并讨论了实施的可行性和障碍、项目的可及性以及该项目对社会凝聚力的影响。
教师们表示该项目实施起来非常可行,且只发现了很少的实施障碍,最突出的障碍是时间限制。感知的项目范围非常广泛,教师们报告说,那些在体育活动方面不太自信的学生与那些对体育活动更有信心的学生的参与度没有差异。最后,该项目被认为对班级的社会凝聚力产生了积极影响。
“全年积极活动”是丹麦学校标准化、灵活且易于实施的项目。未来的研究需要从学生的角度研究实施情况,或研究学生在以竞争为基础的健康项目中的角色和体验。