Wilson Juliana, Maloney Kaylah, Bookman Kelly, Stoneback Jason W, Browne Vaughn A, Ginde Adit, Wallace Mary, Jacknin Gabrielle, Cumbler Ethan, Lewiss Resa E
Emergency Medicine, University of Colorado, Denver, USA.
Emergency Medicine, Thomas Jefferson University, Philadelphia, USA.
Cureus. 2019 May 28;11(5):e4773. doi: 10.7759/cureus.4773.
Study objectives Older adults who sustain hip fractures are susceptible to high rates of morbidity and mortality. The systemic administration of opioids is associated with side effects disproportionately affecting the elderly. The ultrasound-guided fascia iliaca compartment block procedure (FICB) is associated with a reduced patient need for oral and parenteral opioids and with improved functional outcomes. We designed a multi-disciplinary quality improvement initiative to train emergency physicians (EPs) to perform the ultrasound-guided FICB procedure for geriatric hip fracture patients. We examined the lessons derived from the EPs' resistance to implementing a practice-changing behavior. Methods This study was a prospective observational cohort study. We included all emergency department (ED) patients > 65 years with X-ray confirmation of isolated hip fractures. We also enrolled the treating EPs. Patients were enrolled from March 2016 to January 2017 in an urban, academic ED with 100,000 annual visits. The ED ultrasound faculty trained ED faculty and residents in the FICB procedure. Seventeen of 50 attending EPs completed the training: classroom lecture and online narrated video instruction. The hands-on sessions consisted of three stations: scan a human model volunteer to review the sonoanatomy, practice the needle technique using a Blue Phantom Regional Anesthesia Ultrasound Training Block Model (Simulaids, Inc., NY, US), and practice the needle technique using a static simulator. We created a multi-disciplinary geriatric hip fracture order set for the electronic medical record. The attending EPs, caring for eligible patients, were asked to complete a Research Electronic Data Capture (REDCap) survey, and we analyzed the data using descriptive statistics. Results We enrolled 77 geriatric hip fracture patients. Two of the 77 patients received FICB. Thirty-two EPs participated as providers for these patients while 97% of these providers completed the post-intervention survey. Providers used the geriatric hip fracture order set in 10 of 77 encounters. Most EPs did not perform the block because they were not trained or did not feel comfortable performing it. Conclusion Despite the efficacy supported by the literature and training sessions offered, the EPs in this study did not adopt the FICB procedure. Future efforts could include developing a FICB on-call team, increasing the proportion of trained EPs through initial supervised hands-on practice, and partnering financial or education incentives with getting trained.
研究目标 髋部骨折的老年人易出现高发病率和高死亡率。全身性使用阿片类药物会产生副作用,对老年人的影响尤为明显。超声引导下髂筋膜间隙阻滞术(FICB)可减少患者对口服和胃肠外阿片类药物的需求,并改善功能预后。我们设计了一项多学科质量改进计划,以培训急诊医生(EP)为老年髋部骨折患者实施超声引导下FICB手术。我们研究了从急诊医生抵制实施改变实践行为中吸取的经验教训。方法 本研究为前瞻性观察队列研究。我们纳入了所有年龄>65岁、经X线证实为单纯髋部骨折的急诊科(ED)患者。我们还纳入了负责治疗的急诊医生。患者于2016年3月至2017年1月在一家年就诊量达100,000人次的城市学术急诊科入组。急诊超声教员对急诊教员和住院医师进行了FICB手术培训。50名主治急诊医生中有17名完成了培训:课堂讲授和在线旁白视频教学。实践课程包括三个环节:扫描人体模型志愿者以复习超声解剖结构,使用蓝色幻影区域麻醉超声培训阻滞模型(Simulaids公司,美国纽约)练习进针技术,以及使用静态模拟器练习进针技术。我们为电子病历创建了一个多学科老年髋部骨折医嘱集。要求负责治疗符合条件患者的主治急诊医生完成一项研究电子数据采集(REDCap)调查,我们使用描述性统计方法分析数据。结果 我们纳入了77例老年髋部骨折患者。77例患者中有2例接受了FICB。32名急诊医生作为这些患者的提供者参与其中,其中97%的提供者完成了干预后调查。提供者在77次诊疗中有10次使用了老年髋部骨折医嘱集。大多数急诊医生没有实施阻滞,因为他们没有接受过培训或觉得实施起来不自在。结论 尽管有文献支持其有效性并提供了培训课程,但本研究中的急诊医生并未采用FICB手术。未来的努力可包括组建一个FICB随叫随到团队,通过初始的监督实践增加接受培训的急诊医生比例,以及将经济或教育激励措施与接受培训挂钩。