Division of Dentistry, School of Medical Sciences, Faculty of Biology Medicine and Health, University of Manchester, Manchester, UK.
Eur J Dent Educ. 2019 Nov;23(4):471-481. doi: 10.1111/eje.12455. Epub 2019 Aug 18.
Students' perspectives on their learning environment are essential for course development and to enhance the educational experience. In dentistry, there is limited understanding of how students perceive their early clinical training. This study presents students' views on their gradual progression from simulation to patient care and describes the approaches they followed to adapt during this transitioning phase.
A qualitative study design was employed, drawing on focus group discussions conducted with students from the Division of Dentistry at the University of Manchester. The discussions were transcribed verbatim. Data collection and coding process followed the principles of thematic analysis and the inductive approach.
The sample was comprised of 28 undergraduate students, across four focus groups. Thematic analysis generated three key categories: students' immediate perspectives of early clinical training, students' approaches to adapting to the transitioning period and students' suggestions for future improvement. Further, subthemes emerged describing the positive gains which students recognised from their early and gradual clinical involvement and training. Despite experiencing stress and uncertainty, related to insufficient knowledge and immature multitasking skills in the early years of dental training, students were motivated by the clinical environment and identified several ways to adapt to it and enhance their learning. These included additional self-learning resources and simulation opportunities; inter-year group learning activities and further peer support and mentoring.
The current study provided insights into students' experiences of learning through early clinical involvement and gradual transitioning between simulation and clinical environments in dentistry. The findings revealed that whilst students appreciated being involved in the clinic at an early stage, they had to adopt a variety of approaches to link their knowledge, learning and skills between the simulation and clinical environments. Students' suggested additional activities to link the learning gap between the two environments and to enrich their learning.
学生对学习环境的看法对于课程开发和增强教育体验至关重要。在牙科领域,对于学生如何看待早期临床培训,人们的理解有限。本研究介绍了学生对从模拟到患者护理逐步过渡的看法,并描述了他们在过渡阶段适应的方法。
采用定性研究设计,从曼彻斯特大学牙科系的学生中进行焦点小组讨论。讨论内容逐字记录。数据收集和编码过程遵循主题分析和归纳方法的原则。
样本由四个焦点小组的 28 名本科生组成。主题分析产生了三个关键类别:学生对早期临床培训的即时看法、学生适应过渡阶段的方法以及学生对未来改进的建议。此外,还出现了一些子主题,描述了学生从早期和逐步临床参与和培训中认识到的积极收获。尽管在牙科培训的早期阶段,由于知识不足和不成熟的多任务处理技能,学生感到压力和不确定,但他们受到临床环境的激励,并找到了几种适应和增强学习的方法。这些方法包括额外的自学资源和模拟机会、跨年级小组学习活动以及更多的同伴支持和指导。
本研究深入了解了学生通过早期临床参与和在牙科模拟和临床环境之间逐步过渡的学习体验。研究结果表明,尽管学生在早期阶段就热衷于参与临床实践,但他们必须采用多种方法将知识、学习和技能从模拟环境转移到临床环境中。学生建议开展更多活动来弥合两个环境之间的学习差距,并丰富他们的学习。