Fallahi Babak, Manafi-Farid Reyhaneh, Eftekhari Mohammad, Fard-Esfahani Armaghan, Emami-Ardekani Alireza, Geramifar Parham, Akhlaghi Mehdi, Hashemi Taheri Amir Pejman, Beiki Davood
Research Center for Nuclear Medicine, Shariati Hospital, Tehran University of Medical Sciences, Tehran, Iran.
These authors shared first authorship.
Asia Ocean J Nucl Med Biol. 2019 Spring;7(2):129-140. doi: 10.22038/AOJNMB.2019.39392.1263.
In view of somatostatin receptor (SSR) expression on cell membranes of the majority of neuroendocrine tumors (NETs), functional imaging exploiting analogs of SSR alongside the anatomical imaging is the mainstay of this diagnostic modality. In this prospective study, we assessed and directly compared the diagnostic parameters of Ga-DOTATATE PET/CT and Tc-Octreotide SPECT/CT, as well as CT/MRI.
Twenty-five NET patients, either histologically proven or highly suspicious for NET, who were referred for Octreotide Scan were enrolled in this prospective study. They all underwent Tc-Octreotide SPECT/CT and then Ga-DOTATATE PET/CT. A blind interpretation was conducted for each imaging as well as for the previously obtained conventional imaging (CT or MRI). The patient-based and lesion-based analysis were conducted and the results of the three modalities were compared. The histopathologic confirmation or follow-up data were considered as the gold standard. Also, the impact of Ga-DOTATATE PET/CT on the patient's management was assessed.
Overall, 77 lesions in 14 patients, 135 in 19 and 86 in 16 were detected on Tc-Octreotide SPECT/CT, Ga-DOTATATE PET/CT and CT/MRI, respectively. On patient-based analysis, the sensitivity was 65%, 90% and 71% for Tc-Octreotide SPECT/CT, Ga-DOTATATE PET/CT and CT/MRI, respectively. Also, the specificity was 80%, 80% and 75% for Tc-Octreotide SPECT/CT, Ga-DOTATATE PET/CT and CT/MRI, respectively. The correlation between Ga-DOTATATE PET/CT and Tc-Octreotide SPECT/CT results was significant (=0.02; kappa value=0.57), no correlation, however, was depicted with CI (=0.07; kappa value=0.35). On lesion-based analysis, Ga-DOTATATE PET/CT found more organs (=0.02) and lesions (=0.001) in comparison with Tc-Octreotide SPECT/CT and also more lesions in comparison with CT/MRI (=0.003). In addition, comparing with Tc-Octreotide SPECT/CT and CT/MRI, Ga-DOTATATE PET/CT revealed more data in 44% and 36% of the patients, resulting in management modification in 24% and 20%, respectively.
Comparing with Tc-Octreotide SPECT/CT and CT/MRI, Ga-DOTATATE PET/CT provided more sensitivity and specificity in patients with NETs showing more involved organs as well as tumoral lesions. Also, Ga-DOTATATE PET/CT led to change of management in up to one-fourth of the patients, especially in a sub-group re-evaluated for recurrence.
鉴于大多数神经内分泌肿瘤(NETs)细胞膜上存在生长抑素受体(SSR)表达,利用SSR类似物的功能成像联合解剖成像,是这种诊断方式的主要手段。在这项前瞻性研究中,我们评估并直接比较了镓[68Ga] DOTATATE PET/CT、锝[99mTc]奥曲肽SPECT/CT以及CT/MRI的诊断参数。
25例经组织学证实或高度怀疑为NET的患者被纳入这项前瞻性研究,这些患者因奥曲肽扫描而前来就诊。他们均接受了锝[99mTc]奥曲肽SPECT/CT检查,随后接受镓[68Ga] DOTATATE PET/CT检查。对每次成像以及先前获得的传统成像(CT或MRI)进行盲法解读。进行基于患者和基于病灶的分析,并比较三种检查方式的结果。组织病理学确诊或随访数据被视为金标准。此外,评估了镓[68Ga] DOTATATE PET/CT对患者治疗管理的影响。
总体而言,在锝[99mTc]奥曲肽SPECT/CT、镓[68Ga] DOTATATE PET/CT和CT/MRI上分别检测到14例患者中的77个病灶、19例患者中的135个病灶以及16例患者中的86个病灶。在基于患者的分析中,锝[99mTc]奥曲肽SPECT/CT、镓[68Ga] DOTATATE PET/CT和CT/MRI的敏感性分别为65%、90%和71%。同样,锝[99mTc]奥曲肽SPECT/CT、镓[68Ga] DOTATATE PET/CT和CT/MRI的特异性分别为80%、80%和75%。镓[68Ga] DOTATATE PET/CT与锝[99mTc]奥曲肽SPECT/CT结果之间的相关性显著(P=0.02;kappa值=0.57),然而,与CT/MRI未显示相关性(P=0.07;kappa值=0.35)。在基于病灶的分析中,与锝[99mTc]奥曲肽SPECT/CT相比,镓[68Ga] DOTATATE PET/CT发现了更多的器官(P=0.02)和病灶(P=0.001),与CT/MRI相比也发现了更多的病灶(P=0.003)。此外,与锝[99mTc]奥曲肽SPECT/CT和CT/MRI相比,镓[68Ga] DOTATATE PET/CT在44%和36%的患者中发现了更多的数据,分别导致24%和20%患者的治疗管理发生改变。
与锝[99mTc]奥曲肽SPECT/CT和CT/MRI相比,镓[68Ga] DOTATATE PET/CT在NET患者中提供了更高的敏感性和特异性,显示出更多受累器官以及肿瘤病灶。此外,镓[68Ga] DOTATATE PET/CT导致高达四分之一的患者治疗管理发生改变,尤其是在重新评估复发情况的亚组中。