Psychiatry. 2019 Fall;82(3):256-271. doi: 10.1080/00332747.2019.1626200. Epub 2019 Aug 6.
: Little is known about gender differences in mental health, related help-seeking behavior and social support in UK military personnel. : 1714 UK military serving personnel and ex-service veterans were randomly selected if, in a cohort study, they endorsed experiencing a subjective stress, emotional, alcohol or mental health problem in the previous three years. Following exclusions, the final sample size was 1448 (participation rate 84.5%; women n = 219). Structured telephone interviews assessed anxiety, depression, PTSD symptoms, alcohol use, help-seeking and social support occurring both currently and in the past three years. Outcomes were assessed using weighted unadjusted and adjusted logistic regression analyses. : Mental health problems assessed at interview were broadly similar for men and women; for both genders, levels of social support were high. One-fifth of respondents screened positive for probable mental disorder or alcohol misuse; although rates of mental disorder symptoms did not differ by gender, women were significantly less likely than men to report alcohol misuse. Women were significantly more likely to have sought help from formal medical sources but significantly less likely to access informal support such as friends, family or unit welfare sources; reasons for seeking formal medical support were similar for men and women except for problem recognition and acting on advice from others, which were both significantly more common among women. : For military personnel with a history of mental ill-health, women should make greater use of informal support networks while for men, engagement with formal medical help sources should be encouraged.
关于英国军人心理健康、相关求助行为和社会支持方面的性别差异,人们知之甚少。
1714 名英国现役军人和退伍军人,如果他们在一项队列研究中报告在过去三年中经历过主观压力、情绪、酒精或心理健康问题,则会被随机选择。排除后,最终样本量为 1448 人(参与率 84.5%;女性 n=219)。结构化电话访谈评估了当前和过去三年中出现的焦虑、抑郁、创伤后应激障碍症状、酒精使用、求助和社会支持情况。使用加权未调整和调整后的逻辑回归分析评估结果。
访谈中评估的心理健康问题在男性和女性中大致相似;对于两性来说,社会支持水平都很高。五分之一的受访者筛查出可能患有精神障碍或酒精使用障碍;尽管精神障碍症状的发生率没有性别差异,但女性报告酒精使用障碍的可能性明显低于男性。女性更有可能寻求正式医疗资源的帮助,但不太可能获得非正式支持,如朋友、家人或单位福利来源;寻求正式医疗支持的原因对男性和女性来说是相似的,除了问题识别和听从他人建议,这两个原因在女性中更为常见。
对于有心理健康问题史的军人来说,女性应该更多地利用非正式支持网络,而对于男性,应该鼓励他们利用正式的医疗帮助来源。