Department of Psychology, University of Georgia.
J Comp Psychol. 2020 Feb;134(1):84-97. doi: 10.1037/com0000197. Epub 2019 Aug 8.
Adjustment of percussive movements to match the energetic requirements of the task serves as an index of skill in stone-knapping and nut-cracking. In this study, we compared strike-by-strike adjustment of percussive movements in expert bearded capuchin monkeys (Sapajus libidinosus) and (novice and expert) humans cracking palm nuts (Astrocaryum spp.) using stone hammers of varying mass. The monkeys regulated each strike's amplitude and hammer's velocity at impact to a small degree based on the propagation of a fracture in the nut's shell but overall struck a nut with consistent kinetic energy for a given hammer. They showed the smallest movement variability across strikes among all groups. Novice humans took the most strikes to crack a nut among all groups. Expert humans took the fewest strikes among all groups while showing the largest variation in hammer's kinetic energy at impact and largest movement variability across strikes. Overall, our findings confirm that expert humans can adjust their strikes more precisely to meet variable task demands and are more efficient than monkeys or novice humans in cracking nuts, but the findings also show a surprising advantage for expert monkeys over novice humans. The monkeys' strategy of striking with consistent amplitude and velocity is advantageous when hammer mass is adequate to generate sufficient kinetic energy at impact and crack open a nut in few strikes without requiring fine adjustments, explaining why the monkeys are particularly attentive to a stone's mass when choosing it as a hammer. (PsycINFO Database Record (c) 2020 APA, all rights reserved).
调整敲击动作以匹配任务的能量需求是石器敲击和坚果破裂技能的指标。在这项研究中,我们比较了熟练的须冠卷尾猴(Sapajus libidinosus)和(新手和熟练)人类用不同质量的石锤敲击和破裂棕榈坚果(Astrocaryum spp.)时,敲击动作的逐次调整。猴子根据坚果壳中裂缝的传播,在一定程度上调节每次敲击的幅度和锤子撞击时的速度,但总体上以给定锤子撞击时的一致动能来撞击坚果。它们在所有组中显示出最小的敲击运动变化。新手人类在所有组中需要最多的敲击才能敲开坚果。熟练的人类在所有组中需要最少的敲击,同时在撞击时锤子的动能变化最大,敲击之间的运动变化最大。总的来说,我们的研究结果证实,熟练的人类可以更精确地调整他们的敲击以满足变化的任务需求,在敲开坚果方面比猴子或新手人类更有效率,但研究结果也显示了熟练的猴子相对于新手人类具有令人惊讶的优势。当锤子质量足以在撞击时产生足够的动能并在不进行精细调整的情况下在几次敲击内打开坚果时,猴子保持一致的幅度和速度进行敲击的策略是有利的,这解释了为什么猴子在选择锤子时特别注意石头的质量。(PsycINFO 数据库记录(c)2020 APA,保留所有权利)。