使用高频刺激切除初级运动皮层内的肿瘤:基于临床情况的这种通用方法的肿瘤学和功能效率
Resection of tumors within the primary motor cortex using high-frequency stimulation: oncological and functional efficiency of this versatile approach based on clinical conditions.
作者信息
Rossi Marco, Conti Nibali Marco, Viganò Luca, Puglisi Guglielmo, Howells Henrietta, Gay Lorenzo, Sciortino Tommaso, Leonetti Antonella, Riva Marco, Fornia Luca, Cerri Gabriella, Bello Lorenzo
机构信息
1Neurosurgical Oncology Unit, Department of Oncology and Hemato-Oncology.
2Laboratory of Motor Control, Department of Medical Biotechnology and Translational Medicine; and.
出版信息
J Neurosurg. 2019 Aug 9;133(3):642-654. doi: 10.3171/2019.5.JNS19453. Print 2020 Sep 1.
OBJECTIVE
Brain mapping techniques allow one to effectively approach tumors involving the primary motor cortex (M1). Tumor resectability and maintenance of patient integrity depend on the ability to successfully identify motor tracts during resection by choosing the most appropriate neurophysiological paradigm for motor mapping. Mapping with a high-frequency (HF) stimulation technique has emerged as the most efficient tool to identify motor tracts because of its versatility in different clinical settings. At present, few data are available on the use of HF for removal of tumors predominantly involving M1.
METHODS
The authors retrospectively analyzed a series of 102 patients with brain tumors within M1, by reviewing the use of HF as a guide. The neurophysiological protocols adopted during resections were described and correlated with patients' clinical and tumor imaging features. Feasibility of mapping, extent of resection, and motor function assessment were used to evaluate the oncological and functional outcome to be correlated with the selected neurophysiological parameters used for guiding resection. The study aimed to define the most efficient protocol to guide resection for each clinical condition.
RESULTS
The data confirmed HF as an efficient tool for guiding resection of M1 tumors, affording 85.3% complete resection and only 2% permanent morbidity. HF was highly versatile, adapting the stimulation paradigm and the probe to the clinical context. Three approaches were used. The first was a "standard approach" (HF "train of 5," using a monopolar probe) applied in 51 patients with no motor deficit and seizure control, harboring a well-defined tumor, showing contrast enhancement in most cases, and reaching the M1 surface. Complete resection was achieved in 72.5%, and 2% had permanent morbidity. The second approach was an "increased train approach," that is, an increase in the number of pulses (7-9) and of pulse duration, using a monopolar probe. This second approach was applied in 8 patients with a long clinical history, previous treatment (surgery, radiation therapy, chemotherapy), motor deficit at admission, poor seizure control, and mostly high-grade gliomas or metastases. Complete resection was achieved in 87.5% using this approach, along with 0% permanent morbidity. The final approach was a "reduced train approach," which was the combined use of train of 2 or train of 1 pulses associated with the standard approach, using a monopolar or bipolar probe. This approach was used in 43 patients with a long clinical history and poorly controlled seizures, harboring tumors with irregular borders without contrast enhancement (low or lower grade), possibly not reaching the cortical surface. Complete resection was attained in 88.4%, and permanent morbidity was found in 2.3%.
CONCLUSIONS
Resection of M1 tumors is feasible and safe. By adapting the stimulation paradigm and probe appropriately to the clinical context, the best resection and functional results can be achieved.
目的
脑图谱技术使人们能够有效地处理累及初级运动皮层(M1)的肿瘤。肿瘤的可切除性和患者功能的保留取决于在切除过程中通过选择最合适的运动图谱神经生理学范式成功识别运动传导束的能力。高频(HF)刺激技术图谱已成为识别运动传导束最有效的工具,因为它在不同临床环境中具有通用性。目前,关于使用HF切除主要累及M1的肿瘤的数据很少。
方法
作者回顾性分析了102例M1区脑肿瘤患者,以评估HF作为指导的应用情况。描述了切除过程中采用的神经生理学方案,并将其与患者的临床和肿瘤影像学特征相关联。利用图谱的可行性、切除范围和运动功能评估来评估肿瘤学和功能结果,以与用于指导切除的所选神经生理学参数相关联。该研究旨在确定针对每种临床情况指导切除最有效的方案。
结果
数据证实HF是指导M1区肿瘤切除的有效工具,实现了85.3%的完全切除,永久性致残率仅为2%。HF具有高度通用性,可根据临床情况调整刺激范式和探头。采用了三种方法。第一种是“标准方法”(HF“5次脉冲串”,使用单极探头),应用于51例无运动功能障碍且癫痫得到控制的患者,这些患者患有边界清晰的肿瘤,大多数病例有对比增强,且肿瘤累及M1表面。72.5%的患者实现了完全切除,2%的患者有永久性致残。第二种方法是“增加脉冲串方法”,即增加脉冲数量(7 - 9个)和脉冲持续时间,使用单极探头。第二种方法应用于病史较长、曾接受过治疗(手术、放疗、化疗)、入院时有运动功能障碍、癫痫控制不佳且大多为高级别胶质瘤或转移瘤的8例患者。采用这种方法87.5% 的患者实现了完全切除且无永久性致残。最后一种方法是“减少脉冲串方法”,即与标准方法联合使用2次脉冲串或1次脉冲串,使用单极或双极探头。该方法用于43例病史较长且癫痫控制不佳、肿瘤边界不规则且无对比增强(低级别或更低级别)、可能未累及皮质表面的患者。88.4% 的患者实现了完全切除,2.3% 的患者有永久性致残。
结论
切除M1区肿瘤是可行且安全的。通过根据临床情况适当调整刺激范式和探头,可实现最佳的切除效果和功能结果。