College of Civil Engineering, Fuzhou University, Fuzhou, Fujian, China.
Department of Civil Engineering, Ryerson University Toronto, Ontario, Canada.
PLoS One. 2019 Aug 13;14(8):e0220811. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0220811. eCollection 2019.
This paper presents an evaluation of the effectiveness of two types of deceleration markings on freeways in China: fishbone-shaped (FS) markings and edge-rate (ER) markings. An actual 4-lane, 6-km long freeway in Province Hebei was created in a driving simulator and used for the experiments. Three scenarios of deceleration markings were adopted: one without markings, one with FS markings, and the third with ER markings. For each scenario, three traffic flow levels were adopted (low, medium, and heavy). The appropriate dimensions of deceleration markings were first established using relevant design guidelines and then used to develop the simulation scenarios using Multigen Creator software. Sixty drivers carried out the simulation experiments with eye tracker equipment. The adequacy of deceleration markings was analyzed with respect to speed, perceived distance, pupil diameter, and geometric parameters. The results showed that both types of deceleration markings made a certain effect on vehicle speed, drivers'visual behavior, and mental characteristics. However, the effect of the FS markings was more pronounced than that of the ER marking. Specifically, the FS markings showed a speed reduction of 12.3 km/h to 15.2 km/h and a perceived distance of 70 m to 90 m, compared with 6.7 km/h to 9.9 km/h and 40 m to 60 m, respectively, for the ER markings. Application comments of the results are provided in the conclusion.
鱼骨形(FS)标线和边缘率(ER)标线。在驾驶模拟器中创建了河北省一条实际的 4 车道、6 公里长的高速公路,并将其用于实验。采用了三种减速标线场景:一种没有标线,一种有 FS 标线,第三种有 ER 标线。对于每种场景,采用了三种交通流量水平(低、中、高)。首先使用相关设计指南确定了减速标线的适当尺寸,然后使用 Multigen Creator 软件开发模拟场景。六十名驾驶员使用眼动跟踪设备进行了模拟实验。从速度、感知距离、瞳孔直径和几何参数等方面分析了减速标线的充分性。结果表明,这两种类型的减速标线都对车辆速度、驾驶员的视觉行为和心理特征产生了一定的影响。然而,FS 标线的效果比 ER 标线更为明显。具体来说,FS 标线的速度降低了 12.3 公里/小时至 15.2 公里/小时,感知距离增加了 70 米至 90 米,而 ER 标线的速度降低了 6.7 公里/小时至 9.9 公里/小时,感知距离增加了 40 米至 60 米。在结论中提供了对结果的应用意见。