Butts Christopher A, Speer Jacqueline J, Brady John J, Stephenson Ryan J, Langenau Erik, DiTomasso Robert, Fresa Kerin, Becker Michael, Sesso Arthur
J Am Osteopath Assoc. 2019 Sep 1;119(9):578-587. doi: 10.7556/jaoa.2019.101.
Despite a diverse range of curricular advancements to address the difficult transition from classroom learning to clinical training during medical education, hurdles persist. A 4-week course was designed at the Philadelphia College of Osteopathic Medicine (PCOM) to make this transition easier.
To determine whether PCOM students' comfort and preparedness increased after taking a 4-week clinical transition course before third-year clinical clerkships, and to determine whether faculty perceptions of student preparedness and comfort were improved after participation in the course compared with previous third-year students.
Second-year osteopathic medical students at PCOM participated in a 4-week course, Introduction to Clinical Clerkship (I2C). The course included 16 small-group exercises, which all took place before students began their third-year clerkship rotations. The exercises in the course extended beyond the skills learned during their classroom years. Students were given a pre- and postcourse survey to evaluate their comfort level with 58 different aspects of clinical practice. Participating faculty were surveyed to evaluate their perception of student preparedness and comfort compared with previous third-year students who had not undergone the exercise.
After completing the I2C course, third-year osteopathic medical students (n=232) reported increased comfort with 57 of the 58 learning objectives and each of the 5 coded clinical competency areas (patient assessment, effective communication, hospital logistics, procedural skills, and core knowledge) (P<.01). Preceptors reported that students who completed the I2C course were more prepared (54.5%) and more comfortable (63.4%) with clinical duties, as compared with their recollections of previous third-year osteopathic medical students.
Within the 5 competencies, students on average felt more comfortable and were perceived by faculty as better prepared than previous students who had not taken the I2C course. The establishment of a preclinical transition exercise appears to help bridge the gap between the preclinical and clinical years. This learning model allows medical students to feel both more comfortable and better prepared throughout the transition from classroom learning to clinical rotations.
尽管在医学教育过程中,为解决从课堂学习到临床培训的艰难过渡问题,课程有了各种各样的进步,但障碍依然存在。费城骨科医学院(PCOM)设计了一门为期4周的课程,以使这种过渡更加容易。
确定PCOM的学生在三年级临床实习前参加为期4周的临床过渡课程后,其舒适度和准备程度是否有所提高,并确定与之前的三年级学生相比,教师对学生准备程度和舒适度的看法在学生参加该课程后是否得到改善。
PCOM的二年级骨科医学生参加了一门为期4周的课程,即临床实习导论(I2C)。该课程包括16个小组练习,均在学生开始三年级实习轮转之前进行。课程中的练习超出了他们在课堂学习期间所学的技能。学生在课程前后接受了调查,以评估他们对临床实践58个不同方面的舒适度。参与的教师也接受了调查,以评估他们对学生准备程度和舒适度的看法,并与之前未参加该练习的三年级学生进行比较。
完成I2C课程后,三年级骨科医学生(n = 232)报告称,在58个学习目标中的57个以及5个编码的临床能力领域(患者评估、有效沟通、医院后勤、操作技能和核心知识)中的每一个方面,他们的舒适度都有所提高(P <.01)。带教老师报告说,与他们对之前三年级骨科医学生的回忆相比,完成I2C课程的学生对临床职责的准备更充分(54.5%),舒适度更高(63.4%)。
在这5项能力范围内,与之前未参加I2C课程的学生相比,学生平均感觉更舒适,教师也认为他们准备得更好。建立临床前过渡练习似乎有助于弥合临床前和临床阶段之间的差距。这种学习模式使医学生在从课堂学习过渡到临床轮转的整个过程中,既能感到更舒适,又能准备得更充分。