Duca Nicholas S, Glod Susan
Assistant Professor, Division of General Internal Medicine, Penn State Health Milton S. Hershey Medical Center.
Associate Professor, Division of General Internal Medicine, Penn State Health Milton S. Hershey Medical Center.
MedEdPORTAL. 2019 Jan 25;15:10800. doi: 10.15766/mep_2374-8265.10800.
Clinical reasoning is the complex cognitive process that drives the diagnosis of disease and treatment of patients. There is a national call for medical educators to develop clinical reasoning curricula in undergraduate medical education. To address this need, we developed a longitudinal clinical reasoning curriculum for internal medicine clerkship students.
We delivered six 1-hour sessions to approximately 40 students over the 15-week combined medicine-surgery clerkship at Penn State College of Medicine. We developed the content using previous work in clinical reasoning, including the American College of Physicians' Teaching Medicine Series book . Students applied a clinical reasoning diagnostic framework to written cases during each workshop. Each session followed a scaffold approach and built upon previously learned clinical reasoning skills. We administered a pre- and postsurvey to assess students' baseline knowledge of clinical reasoning concepts and perceived confidence in performing clinical reasoning skills. Students also provided open-ended responses regarding the effectiveness of the curriculum.
The curriculum was well received by students and led to increased perceived knowledge of clinical reasoning concepts and increased confidence in applying clinical reasoning skills. Students commented on the usefulness of practicing clinical reasoning in a controlled environment while utilizing a framework that could be deliberately applied to patient care.
The longitudinal clinical reasoning curriculum was effective in reinforcing key concepts of clinical reasoning and allowed for deliberate practice in a controlled environment. The curriculum is generalizable to students in both the preclinical and clinical years.
临床推理是推动疾病诊断和患者治疗的复杂认知过程。目前全国呼吁医学教育工作者在本科医学教育中开发临床推理课程。为满足这一需求,我们为内科实习学生开发了一门纵向临床推理课程。
在宾夕法尼亚州立大学医学院为期15周的内科与外科联合实习期间,我们为大约40名学生提供了6次每次时长1小时的课程。我们利用先前在临床推理方面的工作成果来开发课程内容,包括美国医师协会的《医学教学系列》书籍。在每次研讨会上,学生们将临床推理诊断框架应用于书面病例。每次课程都采用一种支架式教学方法,并基于先前所学的临床推理技能展开。我们进行了课前和课后调查,以评估学生对临床推理概念的基线知识以及对执行临床推理技能的感知信心。学生们还就课程的有效性提供了开放式反馈。
该课程受到学生的好评,并提高了学生对临床推理概念的感知知识以及应用临床推理技能的信心。学生们评价了在可控环境中练习临床推理并使用可特意应用于患者护理的框架的有用性。
纵向临床推理课程有效地强化了临床推理的关键概念,并允许在可控环境中进行刻意练习。该课程可推广至临床前和临床阶段的学生。