Department of Neurology, Neuromuscular Center, Cleveland Clinic, Cleveland, OH, USA.
Neurological Institute Center for Outcomes Research and Evaluation, (NICORE) Cleveland Clinic, Cleveland, OH, USA, and.
Amyotroph Lateral Scler Frontotemporal Degener. 2020 Feb;21(1-2):140-143. doi: 10.1080/21678421.2019.1655060. Epub 2019 Aug 27.
: To estimate the effect of riluzole on the stage-specific risk of progression of ALS. : Patients from the PRO-ACT dataset were staged employing two methods (King's and FT9). Hazard ratios associated with riluzole treatment were estimated for forward transition between stages, using unadjusted and adjusted Markov multistate models. : Of 1903 patients, 1587 had received riluzole. Riluzole-treated patients survived non-significantly longer than those who did not (median 22.9 months vs. 18.3 months from time of initial observation, log rank = 0.16). After adjusting for age and ALSFRS-R slope at first visit, riluzole significantly reduced risk of the following transitions: (1) King's stages: 1->2 (hazard ratio (HR) = 0.81), and 2->3 (HR = 0.82), 4->death (HR = 0.57), and (2) FT9 stages: 1->2 (HR = 0.84), 3->4 (HR = 0.71), and 4->death (HR = 0.67). In contrast, the beneficial effect of riluzole in bulbar-onset patients was in early rather than late King's stages. : This examination of cohorts closely followed in clinical trials finds a beneficial effect of riluzole that is predominantly but not exclusively in later stages of ALS. This analytic framework has utility to discern stage-specific treatment effects, and for refined health economic analyses.
: 评估利鲁唑对 ALS 进展阶段特异性风险的影响。 : 使用两种方法(King 量表和 FT9)对 PRO-ACT 数据集的患者进行分期。使用未经调整和调整后的 Markov 多状态模型,估算利鲁唑治疗与向前转移阶段之间的风险比。 : 在 1903 名患者中,有 1587 名接受了利鲁唑治疗。接受利鲁唑治疗的患者存活时间无显著延长(从首次观察时间开始,中位 22.9 个月比未接受治疗的患者 18.3 个月,对数秩检验 = 0.16)。在调整首次就诊时的年龄和 ALSFRS-R 斜率后,利鲁唑显著降低了以下转变的风险:(1)King 量表:1->2(危险比(HR)=0.81),和 2->3(HR=0.82),4->死亡(HR=0.57),以及(2)FT9 量表:1->2(HR=0.84),3->4(HR=0.71),和 4->死亡(HR=0.67)。相比之下,利鲁唑在延髓发病患者中的有益作用在早期而不是晚期 King 量表中。 : 本研究对临床试验中密切随访的队列进行了检查,发现利鲁唑具有有益作用,但主要局限于 ALS 的晚期阶段。这种分析框架具有辨别治疗效果的作用,可用于更精细的健康经济分析。