Zhu Yingying, Liu Chao, Yurkin Maxim A
Opt Express. 2019 Aug 5;27(16):22827-22845. doi: 10.1364/OE.27.022827.
During the development and application of a scattering algorithm, its accuracy is normally validated by comparing with results of spherical particles given by the exact Mie theory. Being the simplest shape, sphere supports morphology-dependent resonances (MDRs), which cause sharp variations of the scattering properties in narrow size ranges. We show that MDRs may mislead the validation of any volume- or surface-discretization methods, including the discrete dipole approximation (DDA) and, thus, should be explicitly avoided. However, the brute-force DDA simulations can actually capture the narrow peaks in the extinction efficiency over the size parameter, but only if a dipole size parameter is smaller than twice the MDR width. That is much more computationally intensive than typical DDA simulations. We find that a single Lorentzian MDR peak may be split into two due to the symmetry breaking by the DDA discretization. Furthermore, instead of time-consuming high-resolution DDA simulations for reproducing MDR, we developed and validated a significantly more computationally efficient method. It is based, first, on fitting simulated data with one or two Lorentzian peaks combined with a cubic baseline. Second, we use Richardson extrapolation of peak parameters to zero dipole size, exploiting the smooth convergence of these parameters towards the reference Mie values. When applied to two MDRs with relative widths 2 × 10 and 9 × 10, the developed workflow, powered by intensive simulations, reproduces the peak positions with unprecedented accuracy - errors less than 0.07% and 0.4% of their widths, respectively. This extends the way for studying the evolution of the MDR under non-axisymmetric deformations of a sphere or a spheroid.
在散射算法的开发和应用过程中,其准确性通常通过与精确米氏理论给出的球形粒子结果进行比较来验证。作为最简单的形状,球体支持形态依赖共振(MDR),这会导致散射特性在狭窄尺寸范围内急剧变化。我们表明,MDR可能会误导任何体积或表面离散化方法的验证,包括离散偶极近似(DDA),因此应明确避免。然而,蛮力DDA模拟实际上可以捕捉到消光效率随尺寸参数的窄峰,但前提是偶极尺寸参数小于MDR宽度的两倍。这比典型的DDA模拟计算量要大得多。我们发现,由于DDA离散化导致的对称性破坏,单个洛伦兹MDR峰可能会分裂成两个。此外,我们开发并验证了一种计算效率显著更高的方法,而不是通过耗时的高分辨率DDA模拟来再现MDR。它首先基于用一个或两个洛伦兹峰结合三次基线拟合模拟数据。其次,我们利用这些参数向参考米氏值的平滑收敛,通过理查森外推法将峰参数外推到零偶极尺寸。当应用于相对宽度分别为2×10和9×10的两个MDR时,由密集模拟驱动的所开发工作流程以前所未有的精度再现了峰位置——误差分别小于其宽度的0.07%和0.4%。这扩展了研究球体或椭球体非轴对称变形下MDR演变的方法。