Department of Internal Medicine, University of Texas Medical Branch, Galveston, Galveston, TX; Sealy Center on Aging, University of Texas Medical Branch, Galveston, Galveston, TX.
Sealy Center on Aging, University of Texas Medical Branch, Galveston, Galveston, TX.
Chest. 2020 Feb;157(2):427-434. doi: 10.1016/j.chest.2019.08.2187. Epub 2019 Sep 12.
Clinical trials have demonstrated a mortality benefit from lung cancer screening by low-dose CT (LDCT) in current or past tobacco smokers who meet criteria. Potential harms of screening mostly relate to downstream evaluation of abnormal screens. Few data exist on the rates outside of clinical trials of imaging and diagnostic procedures following screening LDCT. We describe rates in the community setting of follow-up imaging and diagnostic procedures after screening LDCT.
We used Clinformatics Data Mart national database to identify enrollees age 55 to 80 year who underwent screening LDCT from January 1, 2016, to December 31, 2016. We assessed rates of follow-up imaging (diagnostic chest CT scan, MRI, and PET) and follow-up procedures (bronchoscopy, percutaneous biopsy, thoracotomy, mediastinoscopy, and thoracoscopy) in the 12 months following LDCT for lung cancer screening. We also assessed these rates in an age-, sex-, and number of comorbidities-matched population that did not undergo LDCT to estimate rates unrelated to the screening LDCT. We then reported the adjusted rate of follow-up testing as the observed rate in the screening LDCT population minus the rate in the non-LDCT population.
Among 11,520 enrollees aged 55 to 80 years who underwent LDCT in 2016, the adjusted rates of follow up 12 months after LDCT examinations were low (17.7% for imaging and 3.1% for procedures). Among procedures, the adjusted rates were 2.0% for bronchoscopy, 1.3% for percutaneous biopsy, 0.9% for thoracoscopy, 0.2% for mediastinoscopy, and 0.4% for thoracotomy. Adjusted rates of follow-up procedures were higher in enrollees undergoing an initial screening LDCT (3.3%) than in those after a second screening examination (2.2%).
In general, imaging and rates of procedures after screening LDCT was low in this commercially insured population.
临床试验表明,在符合条件的当前或过去吸烟的肺癌筛查中,低剂量 CT(LDCT)可降低死亡率。筛查的潜在危害主要与异常筛查的下游评估有关。在临床试验之外,关于筛查 LDCT 后影像学和诊断程序的发生率的数据很少。我们描述了在社区环境中,筛查 LDCT 后进行后续影像学和诊断程序的发生率。
我们使用 Clinformatics Data Mart 全国数据库,从 2016 年 1 月 1 日至 12 月 31 日,确定年龄在 55 岁至 80 岁之间接受筛查 LDCT 的参与者。我们评估了筛查 LDCT 后 12 个月内进行后续影像学检查(诊断性胸部 CT 扫描、MRI 和 PET)和后续程序(支气管镜检查、经皮活检、胸腔镜检查、纵隔镜检查和胸腔镜检查)的比率。我们还在一个年龄、性别和共病数量匹配的未接受 LDCT 的人群中评估了这些比率,以估计与筛查 LDCT 无关的比率。然后,我们报告调整后的随访检测率为筛查 LDCT 人群中的观察率减去非 LDCT 人群中的率。
在 2016 年接受 LDCT 的 11520 名 55 岁至 80 岁的参与者中,LDCT 检查后 12 个月的随访率较低(影像学检查为 17.7%,程序检查为 3.1%)。在程序检查中,支气管镜检查的调整后率为 2.0%,经皮活检为 1.3%,胸腔镜检查为 0.9%,纵隔镜检查为 0.2%,开胸手术为 0.4%。首次接受筛查 LDCT 的参与者(3.3%)的随访程序调整后率高于第二次接受筛查检查的参与者(2.2%)。
一般来说,在这个商业保险人群中,LDCT 筛查后的影像学检查和程序率较低。