Arnaez Juan, Herranz-Rubia Nuria, Garcia-Alix Alfredo
Department of Neonatology, University Hospital of Burgos, Burgos, Spain
Fundación NeNe, Madrid, Spain.
BMJ Support Palliat Care. 2022 Dec;12(e6):e771-e774. doi: 10.1136/bmjspcare-2019-001881. Epub 2019 Sep 16.
To explore end-of-life (EoL) decision-making and palliative care in hypoxic-ischaemic encephalopathy (HIE) nationwide.
A cross-sectional national study on moderate-to-severe HIE in newborns ≥35 weeks' gestational age in 2015, including all 57 level III units that offered hypothermia. Forty-one questions were included to explore how the prognosis is established, as well as timing of the decision-making process, and also how ongoing palliative care is offered.
The main difficulties in EoL decisions lie in the scarce time to make an early, accurate prognosis. Only 20% shared the neurological prognosis with the parents within 72 hours of life, and in only a third of the centres is the nurse present when the prognostic information is given to the family. Almost 50% do not use protocols to order the EoL process. Practically, all centres (91%) reported taking into account the wishes of the parents. However, in 30% the team does not always reach consensus on how the withdrawal process. Specialised psychological support is available in 54% of the hospitals; in more than 50%, interviews are not arranged to examine the grieving process with parents.
There are four areas for improvement in the comprehensive, multidisciplinary approach to the EoL decision in the patient with HIE: (1) the need for EoL and interdisciplinary palliative care protocols, (2) participation of nurses in the process and improvement in the nurse-physician communication, (3) psychological support for parents involved in the EoL decisions and (4) implementation of strategies to give support during the grieving process.
在全国范围内探讨缺氧缺血性脑病(HIE)患者的临终决策和姑息治疗。
2015年对孕周≥35周的中度至重度新生儿HIE进行了一项全国性横断面研究,纳入了所有提供低温治疗的57个三级医疗单位。研究包含41个问题,以探讨如何确定预后、决策过程的时机以及如何提供持续的姑息治疗。
临终决策的主要困难在于难以在早期准确预测预后。仅有20%在出生后72小时内与父母分享神经学预后,在仅三分之一的中心,向家属提供预后信息时护士在场。近50%的中心未使用协议来安排临终过程。实际上,所有中心(91%)报告称会考虑父母的意愿。然而,在30%的中心,团队对于撤离过程并不总能达成共识。54%的医院提供专门的心理支持;超过50%的医院未安排与父母探讨悲伤过程的访谈。
在对HIE患者进行临终决策的综合多学科方法中,有四个方面需要改进:(1)需要制定临终和跨学科姑息治疗协议;(2)护士参与决策过程并改善护士与医生之间的沟通;(3)为参与临终决策的父母提供心理支持;(4)实施在悲伤过程中给予支持的策略。