Apker Julie, Shank Scott, Baker Maggie, Hatten Kristen, VanSweden Sally
School of Communication, Western Michigan University , Kalamazoo, Michigan , USA.
Internal Medicine Hospital Specialists, Bronson HealthCare Group , Kalamazoo, Michigan , USA.
Hosp Top. 2019 Oct-Dec;97(4):156-164. doi: 10.1080/00185868.2019.1667284. Epub 2019 Sep 18.
This study identifies actual hospitalist best communication practices that optimize patient interactions in a busy hospital context. We observed and rated 36 hospitalists and 206 patient encounters using the Kalamazoo Essential Elements of Communication Checklist-Adapted (KEECC-A). We collected descriptive statistics of checklist scores and thematically analyzed fieldnotes to identify communication patterns. Results show hospitalists score highest and most frequently use three of seven KEECC-A dimensions: builds a relationship, shares information, and gathers information. We first identify exemplar behaviors and then provide statistical comparisons by professional and hospital tenure, gender, and day of rounding observed for these three dimensions. Male hospitalists scored higher than females for shares information and significant differences were found for gender between cross-sex patient-hospitalist interactions. Hospitalists early in their professional and hospital tenure received significantly lower ratings than mid-to-late career hospitalists in the three KEECC dimensions. Hospitalists observed on the first day of rounding received significantly higher ratings than those observed on a middle or last day. We offer interpretations to explain study findings and suggest interventions to help hospitalists with less-than-desirable communication skills.
本研究确定了实际的住院医师最佳沟通实践,这些实践可在繁忙的医院环境中优化医患互动。我们使用改编后的卡拉马祖沟通基本要素清单(KEECC-A)对36名住院医师和206次医患会面进行了观察和评分。我们收集了清单分数的描述性统计数据,并对实地记录进行了主题分析,以确定沟通模式。结果显示,住院医师在KEECC-A的七个维度中的三个维度上得分最高且使用频率最高:建立关系、分享信息和收集信息。我们首先确定典型行为,然后按专业和医院任期、性别以及观察到的查房日对这三个维度进行统计比较。男性住院医师在分享信息方面的得分高于女性,并且在异性医患互动中发现了性别之间的显著差异。在专业和医院任期早期的住院医师在KEECC的三个维度上的评分明显低于职业生涯中期至后期的住院医师。在查房第一天观察到的住院医师的评分明显高于在中间或最后一天观察到的住院医师。我们对研究结果进行了解释,并提出了干预措施,以帮助沟通技巧欠佳的住院医师。