Revranche M, Husky M, Kovess-Masfety V
Faculté de psychologie, université de Bordeaux, 33000 Bordeaux, France.
Laboratoire de Psychologie EA4139, institut universitaire de France, université de Bordeaux, 33000 Bordeaux, France.
Encephale. 2019 Dec;45(6):513-521. doi: 10.1016/j.encep.2019.07.012. Epub 2019 Sep 18.
The current study aims to identify the factors associated with the use of psychotherapy among adults with a history of suicide attempt.
A large cross-sectional survey (N=22,138) was conducted in four regions of France to characterize mental health care needs in the general population. Data were collected between April and June 2005 by trained interviewers using a computer-assisted telephone interviewing system (CATI). Sociodemographics, past-year mental disorders, lifetime and 12-month history of suicide attempts, and use of psychotherapy were assessed.
Overall, 7.1% of adults reported having undergone psychotherapy in the course of their life, and 2.0% in the previous 12 months. While 8.3% of adults with a lifetime suicide attempt (prior to the previous 12 months) underwent a psychotherapy in the previous 12 months, 27.5% of adults with a past-year suicide attempt underwent a psychotherapy in the previous 12 months. Psychotherapy was provided by psychiatrists (49.5%), psychologists (28.2%), and psychoanalysts (10.6%). While the frequency of psychotherapy sessions was greater among those with a prior attempt as compared to those with no prior attempt [Chi (10)=21.35, P=.019], there was no difference in therapy duration [Chi (8)=6.71, P=.568]. Compared to adults who did not report a prior attempt, those with a prior suicide attempt were 3,3 more likely to undergo psychotherapy with a psychologist [AOR=3.31 (2.54-4.31)]. Among adults with a prior suicide attempt, increased odds of undergoing a psychotherapy in the course of their life was predicted by higher education [AOR=2.81 (1.56-5.06)], living in the Paris region [AOR=2.06 (1.32-3.23)], and being a woman [AOR=1.50 (1.08-2.09)]. Increased odds of undergoing a psychotherapy in the previous 12 months was predicted by a major depressive disorder [AOR=2.59 (1.57-4.27)], any anxiety disorder [AOR=1.79 (1.07-2.97)], higher education [AOR=3.60 (1.29-10.0)], living in a city of 20,000 to 100,000 inhabitants [AOR=2.71 (1.13-6.50)] and more [AOR=2.50 (1.12-5.57)] (outside of the Paris region), a 2000 to 3000 euros monthly income [AOR=2.37 (1.15-4.85)].
One third of adults with a lifetime suicide attempt and close to half of those with a past-year attempt have received some form of psychotherapy in the course of their life. In line with prior work, higher education and income level predicted past-year use of psychotherapy among adults with a prior suicide attempt. These findings highlight the association between major depressive disorder or anxiety disorders and increased odds of undergoing psychotherapy in the previous 12 months among adults with prior attempt. While pharmacological treatment, inpatient hospitalizations for mental health problems, visits with a general practitioner or specialized physician are free of charge in France, psychotherapy provided by psychologists or psychotherapists is currently not covered by the French Social Security health care system. As the treatment of mental disorders plays an important role in the reduction of suicide risk, supporting evidence-based psychotherapy through its reimbursement appears to be an important public health issue.
本研究旨在确定有自杀未遂史的成年人使用心理治疗的相关因素。
在法国四个地区进行了一项大型横断面调查(N = 22138),以描述普通人群的心理健康护理需求。2005年4月至6月期间,由经过培训的访谈员使用计算机辅助电话访谈系统(CATI)收集数据。评估了社会人口统计学、过去一年的精神障碍、终身和12个月的自杀未遂史以及心理治疗的使用情况。
总体而言,7.1%的成年人报告在其一生中接受过心理治疗,在过去12个月中这一比例为2.0%。在有终身自杀未遂史(在过去12个月之前)的成年人中,8.3%在过去12个月中接受了心理治疗,而在过去一年有自杀未遂史的成年人中,27.5%在过去12个月中接受了心理治疗。心理治疗由精神科医生(49.5%)、心理学家(28.2%)和精神分析师(10.6%)提供。与没有既往自杀未遂史的人相比,有既往自杀未遂史的人接受心理治疗的频率更高[卡方(10)=21.35,P = 0.019],但治疗持续时间没有差异[卡方(8)=6.71,P = 0.568]。与未报告有既往自杀未遂史的成年人相比,有既往自杀未遂史的人接受心理学家心理治疗的可能性高3.3倍[调整后比值比(AOR)=3.31(2.54 - 4.31)]。在有既往自杀未遂史的成年人中,接受过高等教育[AOR = 2.81(1.56 - 5.06)]、居住在巴黎地区[AOR = 2.06(1.32 - 3.23)]以及女性[AOR = 1.50(1.08 - 2.09)]预示着其一生中接受心理治疗的几率增加。过去12个月中接受心理治疗几率增加的因素包括重度抑郁症[AOR = 2.59(1.57 - 4.27)]、任何焦虑症[AOR = 1.79(1.07 - 2.97)]、高等教育[AOR = 3.60(1.29 - 10.0)]、居住在人口为2万至10万的城市[AOR = 2.71(1.13 - 6.50)]以及更多[AOR = 2.50(1.12 - 5.57)](巴黎地区以外)、月收入2000至3000欧元[AOR = 2.37(1.15 - 4.85)]。
有终身自杀未遂史的成年人中有三分之一以及过去一年有自杀未遂史的成年人中近一半在其一生中接受过某种形式的心理治疗。与先前的研究一致,高等教育和收入水平预示着有既往自杀未遂史的成年人在过去一年中使用心理治疗的情况。这些发现凸显了重度抑郁症或焦虑症与有既往自杀未遂史的成年人在过去12个月中接受心理治疗几率增加之间的关联。在法国,药物治疗、因心理健康问题住院、看全科医生或专科医生都是免费的,但心理学家或心理治疗师提供的心理治疗目前不在法国社会保障医疗系统的覆盖范围内。由于精神障碍的治疗在降低自杀风险方面起着重要作用,通过报销来支持循证心理治疗似乎是一个重要的公共卫生问题。