From the Division of Orthopaedic Surgery, Scripps Clinic, La Jolla, CA.
J Am Acad Orthop Surg. 2020 May 15;28(10):e440-e447. doi: 10.5435/JAAOS-D-19-00261.
Historically, hip precautions have been prescribed after total hip arthroplasty (THA) to limit certain motions felt to place the arthroplasty construct in a position at increased risk for dislocation. This study aimed to determine whether relaxed hip precautions after primary THA done via a posterolateral approach resulted in a higher early dislocation rate compared with standard hip precautions.
The hip precaution protocol was changed from standard to relaxed at our institution for all patients with THA in December 2016. One cohort had THA in the 18 months before the protocol change and had standard hip precautions, and the second cohort had THA in the 18 months after the protocol change and had relaxed precautions. We determined the early dislocation rate (within 3 months postoperatively) for both cohorts and controlled for selected demographic and surgical details.
The standard precaution group included 597 primary THAs and the relaxed precaution group included 692 hips. No notable differences were found between the groups in terms of age at surgery, body mass index, sex, laterality, or diagnosis. Early dislocation occurred in seven hips (1.2%) in the standard precaution cohort and in nine hips (1.4%) in the relaxed precaution cohort. This difference was not statistically significant (P = 0.77).
The results of our study suggest that well-trained, high-volume surgeons may potentially relax hip precautions prescribed to the patients after primary THA done via a posterolateral approach without subjecting patients to a markedly higher incidence of dislocation. However, unlike previous studies, this study controlled for femoral head size, which is a well-known confounder for dislocation risk.
从历史上看,髋关节预防措施一直被规定用于全髋关节置换术(THA)后,以限制某些被认为会使关节置换结构处于增加脱位风险的位置的运动。本研究旨在确定与标准髋关节预防措施相比,通过后外侧入路进行初次 THA 后放松髋关节预防措施是否会导致早期脱位率增加。
2016 年 12 月,我院对所有接受 THA 的患者改变了髋关节预防措施的方案,从标准改为放松。一组患者在方案改变前的 18 个月内接受 THA,并采用标准髋关节预防措施,另一组患者在方案改变后的 18 个月内接受 THA,并采用放松预防措施。我们确定了两组的早期脱位率(术后 3 个月内),并控制了选定的人口统计学和手术细节。
标准预防组包括 597 例初次 THA,放松预防组包括 692 髋。在手术时的年龄、体重指数、性别、侧别或诊断方面,两组之间没有明显差异。标准预防组中有 7 髋(1.2%)和放松预防组中有 9 髋(1.4%)发生早期脱位。这一差异没有统计学意义(P=0.77)。
我们的研究结果表明,对于经过后外侧入路的初次 THA,经过培训的、高容量的外科医生可能可以放松髋关节预防措施,而不会使患者明显增加脱位的发生率。然而,与以前的研究不同,本研究控制了股骨头大小,这是脱位风险的一个众所周知的混杂因素。