Department of Psychology, Indiana University-Purdue University Indianapolis, Indianapolis, IN, United States.
Department of Family Medicine, The Ohio State University, Columbus, OH, United States.
Pain. 2019 Oct;160(10):2229-2240. doi: 10.1097/j.pain.0000000000001634.
We conducted a randomized controlled trial of an individually tailored, virtual perspective-taking intervention to reduce race and socioeconomic status (SES) disparities in providers' pain treatment decisions. Physician residents and fellows (n = 436) were recruited from across the United States for this two-part online study. Providers first completed a bias assessment task in which they made treatment decisions for virtual patients with chronic pain who varied by race (black/white) and SES (low/high). Providers who demonstrated a treatment bias were randomized to the intervention or control group. The intervention consisted of personalized feedback about their bias, real-time dynamic interactions with virtual patients, and videos depicting how pain impacts the patients' lives. Treatment bias was re-assessed 1 week later. Compared with the control group, providers who received the tailored intervention had 85% lower odds of demonstrating a treatment bias against black patients and 76% lower odds of demonstrating a treatment bias against low SES patients at follow-up. Providers who received the intervention for racial bias also showed increased compassion for patients compared with providers in the control condition. Group differences did not emerge for provider comfort in treating patients. Results suggest an online intervention that is tailored to providers according to their individual treatment biases, delivers feedback about these biases, and provides opportunities for increased contact with black and low SES patients, can produce substantial changes in providers' treatment decisions, resulting in more equitable pain care. Future studies should examine how these effects translate to real-world patient care and the optimal timing/dose of the intervention.
我们进行了一项随机对照试验,研究了一种个性化的虚拟换位思考干预措施,以减少提供者在疼痛治疗决策中的种族和社会经济地位(SES)差异。这项在线研究的参与者包括来自美国各地的医师住院医师和研究员(n=436)。首先,参与者完成了一项偏见评估任务,在该任务中,他们为患有慢性疼痛的虚拟患者做出治疗决策,这些患者的种族(黑/白)和 SES(低/高)不同。表现出治疗偏见的提供者被随机分配到干预组或对照组。干预措施包括对其偏见的个性化反馈、与虚拟患者的实时动态互动以及描绘疼痛如何影响患者生活的视频。一周后重新评估治疗偏见。与对照组相比,接受个性化干预的提供者对黑人患者表现出治疗偏见的可能性降低了 85%,对 SES 较低的患者表现出治疗偏见的可能性降低了 76%。接受种族偏见干预的提供者与对照组相比,对患者的同情心也有所增加。在治疗患者的舒适度方面,组间没有差异。结果表明,根据提供者的个体治疗偏见量身定制、提供有关这些偏见的反馈并提供与黑人和 SES 较低的患者增加接触机会的在线干预措施,可以显著改变提供者的治疗决策,从而实现更公平的疼痛护理。未来的研究应该探讨这些效果如何转化为实际的患者护理以及干预措施的最佳时间/剂量。