Zimmerman M, Coryell W, Pfohl B, Stangl D
J Affect Disord. 1985 Jan-Feb;8(1):37-45. doi: 10.1016/0165-0327(85)90070-9.
We examined the relationship between the DST and 4 definitions of endogenous depression: DSM-III, Feinberg and Carroll, Newcastle and RDC. Endogenous patients had a significantly higher rate of nonsuppression than nonendogenous patients according to the DSM-III and Newcastle definitions but not according to the RDC and Feinberg and Carroll criteria. Moreover, the relationship between the DST and the DSM-III and Newcastle definitions was significant even after individually controlling for age, psychosis and weight loss. We review the literature on the relationship between the DST and the RDC definition of endogenous depression and suggest that interstudy differences in criteria application may be partially responsible for the inconsistent results across studies.
我们研究了地塞米松抑制试验(DST)与内源性抑郁的4种定义之间的关系:《精神疾病诊断与统计手册》第三版(DSM-III)、范伯格和卡罗尔的定义、纽卡斯尔定义以及研究诊断标准(RDC)。根据DSM-III和纽卡斯尔定义,内源性患者的未被抑制率显著高于非内源性患者,但根据RDC以及范伯格和卡罗尔的标准则不然。此外,即使分别对年龄、精神病和体重减轻进行控制后,DST与DSM-III和纽卡斯尔定义之间的关系仍然显著。我们回顾了关于DST与内源性抑郁的RDC定义之间关系的文献,并指出研究标准应用方面的差异可能部分导致了各研究结果的不一致。