Department of Integrative Biology, University of Colorado, Denver, Denver, CO 80217.
School of Education and Human Development, University of Colorado, Denver, Denver, CO 80217.
CBE Life Sci Educ. 2019 Dec;18(4):ar50. doi: 10.1187/cbe.18-10-0204.
Identity production is a complex process in which a person determines who he or she is via internal dialogue and sociocultural participation. Understanding identity production is important in biology education, because students' identities impact classroom experiences and their willingness to persist in the discipline. Thus, we suggest that educators foster spaces where students can engage in producing science identities that incorporate positive perceptions of who they are and what they have experienced. We used Holland's theory of identity and Urrieta's definitions of conceptual identity production (CIP) and procedural identity production (PIP) to explore the process of students' science identity production. We interviewed 26 students from five sections of a general biology course for majors at one higher education institution. The interview protocol included items about students' identities, influential experiences, perceptions of science, and perceptions of their classroom communities. From the interviews, we developed hierarchical coding schemes that focused on characterizing students' CIP and PIP. Here, we describe how students' socially constructed identities (race, gender, etc.) and their experiences may have impacted the production of their science identities. We found that authoring (i.e., making meaning of) experiences and recognition by others as a community member influenced students' science identity production.
身份认同的产生是一个复杂的过程,在这个过程中,一个人通过内部对话和社会文化参与来确定自己的身份。在生物教育中,理解身份认同的产生很重要,因为学生的身份认同会影响他们的课堂体验以及他们在学科中的坚持意愿。因此,我们建议教育者创造空间,让学生能够参与到产生科学身份认同的过程中,这种身份认同将包含他们对自己的积极认知以及他们的经历。我们使用 Holland 的身份认同理论和 Urrieta 的概念身份认同产生 (CIP) 和程序身份认同产生 (PIP) 的定义来探索学生的科学身份认同产生过程。我们采访了一所高等教育机构的一个普通生物学专业五个班级的 26 名学生。访谈的内容包括学生的身份认同、有影响力的经历、对科学的看法以及对课堂社区的看法。从访谈中,我们制定了分层编码方案,重点描述学生的 CIP 和 PIP。在这里,我们描述了学生的社会建构身份(种族、性别等)和他们的经历如何可能影响他们的科学身份认同的产生。我们发现,创作(即对经历进行意义构建)和被他人认可为社区成员会影响学生的科学身份认同的产生。