Department of Psychiatry, Massachusetts General Hospital, Boston, MA; Department of Psychiatry, North Shore Medical Center, Salem, MA.
Department of Psychiatry, Vanderbilt University Medical Center, Nashville, TN.
Psychosomatics. 2020 Jan-Feb;61(1):19-23. doi: 10.1016/j.psym.2019.08.010. Epub 2019 Sep 9.
Oral presentations at academic conferences typically describe recent or ongoing research projects or provide literature reviews. However, conversion of these presentations into full-length journal articles is not routine.
We sought to assess the frequency with which oral presentations at the Academy of Consultation-Liaison Psychiatry's annual meetings from 2012 to 2018 were turned into peer-reviewed publications and review the factors that affected publication of them.
Conference presentation titles and authors from the 2012-2018 Academy of Consultation-Liaison Psychiatry Annual Meetings were searched using PubMed to find corresponding published reports by the presenters. Data were organized in an Excel spreadsheet, and the time to publication, the journals in which they were published, and general content areas were recorded and analyzed.
Of the 287 oral presentations delivered during the study period, 47% were published in a peer-reviewed journal. Articles were published in 72 different journals; the journals that published the most articles were Psychosomatics, General Hospital Psychiatry, Psycho-oncology, Academic Psychiatry, and the Journal of General Internal Medicine. The most common subspecialty topics of the published articles were neuropsychiatry, psycho-oncology, surgery and transplantation, and delirium. The mean time to publication after presentation was 1 year.
Knowledge of the rate at which presentations are converted into peer-reviewed publications can be used to enhance the academic success of presenters, and strategies to enhance the rate of publication (e.g., by coaching on scientific writing or by selecting oral presentations with the highest publication potential) can be established.
学术会议上的口头报告通常描述最近或正在进行的研究项目或提供文献综述。然而,将这些报告转化为完整的期刊文章并不是常规做法。
我们旨在评估 2012 年至 2018 年咨询联络精神病学学会年会上的口头报告转化为同行评议出版物的频率,并回顾影响其发表的因素。
使用 PubMed 搜索 2012-2018 年咨询联络精神病学学会年会的会议报告标题和作者,以找到报告人相应的已发表报告。将数据整理到 Excel 电子表格中,并记录和分析发表时间、发表的期刊以及一般内容领域。
在研究期间,287 次口头报告中有 47%发表在同行评议的期刊上。文章发表在 72 种不同的期刊上;发表文章最多的期刊是《身心医学》《综合医院精神病学》《心理肿瘤学》《学术精神病学》和《普通内科医学杂志》。已发表文章中最常见的亚专科主题是神经精神病学、心理肿瘤学、外科和移植、谵妄。口头报告发表后的平均发表时间为 1 年。
了解报告转化为同行评议出版物的比率,可以用来提高报告人的学术成功,并且可以制定提高出版率的策略(例如,通过指导科学写作或选择具有最高出版潜力的口头报告)。