Ruhr University Bochum, LWL-University Hospital Bochum, LWL-Institute of Mental Health, Bochum, Germany.
Department of Psychiatry, Ruhr University Bochum, LWL-University Hospital Bochum, Bochum, Germany.
Health Soc Care Community. 2020 Mar;28(2):467-474. doi: 10.1111/hsc.12879. Epub 2019 Oct 27.
Coercive measures are a sensitive, much-discussed ethical and legal issue in the psychiatric context. Hence, the identification of their predictors and ways of prevention are of utmost importance. The present study aimed to determine the impact of the social-psychiatric services (SPS) in North Rhine Westphalia (NRW) on involuntary admissions according to the German Mental Health Act and to identify predictors for the reduction of these involuntary admissions. A dataset including details from 31 districts and 23 towns in NRW over a time period of 10 years (2005-2014) was analysed regarding the number of involuntary admissions, gender and age of admitted patients, and person/institution initiating the compulsory act. All 56 SPS in NRW were contacted for information on the number of clients/contacts, home visits, areas of responsibility and their involvement in involuntary admissions. Thirty SPS participated in the survey. We found a significant increase of involuntary admissions over time with significantly higher proportions of male patients and patients younger than 60 years in every year. Regarding the characteristics of SPS, a negative correlation between the number of clients contacting the SPS on their own initiative and low-income households was observed. Additionally, the number of clients contacting the SPS on their own initiative was significantly higher in districts/towns associated with lower involuntary admission rates. These data suggest that patient-based factors were of great importance in the context of involuntary admissions. Furthermore, the SPS and home treatment should be strengthened and intensified to achieve lower involuntary admission rates.
强制治疗措施在精神科领域是一个备受关注且颇具争议的伦理和法律问题。因此,确定其预测因素和预防方法至关重要。本研究旨在确定北莱茵-威斯特法伦州(NRW)的社会精神病服务(SPS)对德国《精神卫生法》规定的非自愿入院的影响,并确定减少这些非自愿入院的预测因素。分析了一个包含 NRW 31 个区和 23 个城镇的数据,时间跨度为 10 年(2005-2014 年),内容包括非自愿入院的人数、入院患者的性别和年龄以及启动强制治疗的个人/机构。NRW 所有 56 个 SPS 都被联系以获取有关客户/联系人数量、家访、责任领域以及他们参与非自愿入院的信息。有 30 个 SPS 参与了调查。我们发现,非自愿入院的人数随着时间的推移而显著增加,每年男性患者和 60 岁以下患者的比例都显著更高。关于 SPS 的特点,我们发现与低收入家庭相关的 SPS 自行联系客户的数量与非自愿入院率呈负相关。此外,自行联系 SPS 的客户数量在与非自愿入院率较低的地区/城镇中显著更高。这些数据表明,患者因素在非自愿入院的情况下非常重要。此外,应该加强和深化 SPS 和家庭治疗,以实现较低的非自愿入院率。