Kahar Payal, Chapman Carol, Gupta Jayanta
Department of Health Sciences, Florida Gulf Coast University, Fort Myers, Florida, USA.
Department of Dental Hygiene, Florida Southwestern College, Fort Myers, Florida, USA.
Int J Dent. 2019 Sep 23;2019:1608329. doi: 10.1155/2019/1608329. eCollection 2019.
To determine and compare OHRQoL (oral-health-related quality of life) using the Geriatric Oral Health Assessment Index (GOHAI-12) and Oral Health Impact Profile (OHIP-14) among patients receiving hemodialysis (HD).
Face-to-face interviews and intraoral examinations were conducted among 70 patients. Mann-Whitney test and Kruskal-Wallis test were used to compare each item score with demographics and dental and overall health status.
The mean number of years on dialysis was 4.7 ± 7.5 yrs; the mean number of teeth present was 19.7 ± 11.04; median values of OHRQoL using GOHAI-12 and OHIP-14 were 52 and 64. Within GOHAI-12, limiting food ( 0.043), uncomfortable eating in front of people ( 0.045), limiting contact with people ( 0.046), and eating without discomfort ( 0.011) were significantly associated with females. Being worried ( 0.040) and self-conscious ( 0.048) were significant for age groups ≤65 years. Prevented from speaking was associated with >20 teeth ( 0.016). Being worried about oral health was associated with number of years on dialysis ( 0.042). Within OHIP-14, speech was associated with number of teeth present ( 0.024). Total inability to function was significantly associated with race ( 0.018), number of teeth ( 0.028), and edentulousness ( 0.031).
GOHAI-12 was more effective than OHIP-14 in assessing OHRQoL. However, most subjective experiences did not correlate with clinical findings. Systemic health issue like end-stage renal disease affecting QoL might have taken precedence over dental problems. Clinical assessments should be inherent in oral-health evaluation and there should be cooperation between nephrologists and dentists in promoting oral health and treating systemic conditions among HD patients.
使用老年口腔健康评估指数(GOHAI - 12)和口腔健康影响程度量表(OHIP - 14)来测定并比较接受血液透析(HD)患者的口腔健康相关生活质量(OHRQoL)。
对70名患者进行面对面访谈和口腔内检查。采用曼 - 惠特尼检验和克鲁斯卡尔 - 沃利斯检验来比较各项目得分与人口统计学、牙齿及整体健康状况。
透析的平均年限为4.7±7.5年;现存牙齿的平均数量为19.7±11.04颗;使用GOHAI - 12和OHIP - 14时OHRQoL的中位数分别为52和64。在GOHAI - 12中,限制饮食(0.043)、在他人面前进食不适(0.045)、限制与人接触(0.046)以及进食无不适(0.011)与女性显著相关。担忧(0.040)和自觉(0.048)在年龄≤65岁的人群中具有显著性。说话受限与牙齿数>20颗相关(0.016)。对口腔健康的担忧与透析年限相关(0.042)。在OHIP - 14中,言语与现存牙齿数相关(0.024)。完全无法正常功能与种族(0.018)、牙齿数(0.028)和无牙状态(0.031)显著相关。
在评估OHRQoL方面,GOHAI - 12比OHIP - 14更有效。然而,大多数主观体验与临床检查结果并无关联。像终末期肾病这样影响生活质量的全身性健康问题可能比牙齿问题更为突出。临床评估应成为口腔健康评估的固有组成部分,并且肾病科医生和牙医之间应开展合作,以促进HD患者的口腔健康并治疗全身性疾病。